- May 6, 2003
The accusations by respected and veteran members of other trading forums and the action taken by site owner Baron on Elitetrader speaks for itself as a strong argument against dbphoenix, as does the Futures.io banishment. Timsk's ad hominem suggestion that me mentioning this shows my poor character and that the cloud of suspicion over dbphoenix is wishy-washy clearly suggests favortism more than weak argumentation on my part.
So far as I see it all Timsk has done is point up that dip has done nothing untoward here on T2W. You may, or may not, agree with his (dbp's, that is) approach to price action analysis and associated trading. And you may, or may not think he is a successful trader himself (he has never made much comment about his own trading).
He sells an e-book (pretty cheap it is too) which is freely admitted, but he doesn't use the boards to constantly advertise and push it.
So what's the beef about what he's done on T2W? You seem to be condemning him by what you may have heard he may have done elsewhere when the evidence that matters is what he has done here.