I think this is semantical, essentially we are saying same thing but you are confusing cause and effect.

As far as the maths basis of charts go , which is what I am mainly concerned about. Every chart must have a y and an x axis, the dependent axis depends on the independent axis (x).

So every future point in time will have a corresponding price sometime in future, even when there are temporary price gaps.

In maths this is the dependent variable price depending on the independent (x) time, and this is the law when it comes to charts, and it is totally objective. Therefore price IS a calculation by time, every price is calculated by what time it is . These are the effects.

So Whaever the cause behind the production of price , eg) what people agree upon or feel about an irrelevant issue but is may be what traders need to solve to be profitable.

Repeating once again -

As far as the maths basis of charts go , which is what I am mainly concerned about. Every chart must have a y and an x axis, the dependent axis depends on the independent axis (x).

So every future point in time will have a corresponding price sometime in future, even when there are temporary price gaps.

In maths this is the dependent variable price depending on the independent (x) time, and this is the law when it comes to charts, and it is totally objective. Therefore price IS a calculation by time, every price is calculated by what time it is . These are the effects.

So Whaever the cause behind the production of price , eg) what people agree upon or feel about an irrelevant issue but is may be what traders need to solve to be profitable.

Repeating once again -

**This is a discussion purely about the objective CALCULATION of TA**. Removing the y axis would seem to further the subjectivity of the chart, indeed half a chart and this to me is UNOBJECTIVE and I would be very sceptical of that.Your thesis appears to be based on the ability to predict future price as a result of past price. No one has ever been able to demonstrate that this can be done. And it is unlikely that anyone will ever be able to do so due to the nature of trading.

But best of luck to you.

Likes:
seekingTruth16 and barjon