Should WallStreet1928 be given 1 last chance to post live calls this week?

[MajorDutch]

Lets put it to the members. Give him a chance to post live calls this week if he steps out of line then ban him.

 

[Doomberg]

I don't know the firm very well but i see from the website that it's part of in the money stocks. The one thing that sticks out to me is that they think that Dax will be flying up by about 700 points before xmas. I'm watching this call because i believe it to be incorrect. Here's the pic from the wallstreet1928 blog:


http://api.ning.com/files/NTPFNk1hn...d45s8EzLoTdKSVdOoa*In/DAXPERFORMANCEINDEX.png

 

[VielGeld]

I dunno 'bout that guy. Either he's for real and his ego just gets in the way of everything, or he's a fraud and his ego just gets in the way of everything.

I would have liked to see some genuine live calls, but he also did overstep his boundaries.

I'm neutral on this one.

 

[Lightning McQueen]

Lets put it to the members. Give him a chance to post live calls this week if he steps out of line then ban him.

how many chances does he need dutch? barjon clearly laid out rules to abide by. what did ws then go do, took the **** as he always has done "Trade2win want me back, they're suffering from a loss of revenue??hahaha" when that wasn't the truth at all was it. in the past ws tried sig linking, post linking, having deleted his direct links and warned, he'd sneak them back on! he will take the **** again given the chance. this time it's sure to be worse as he wants to manage our money, great! roll on the ws fund!

i tell you what, why don't all his chums and supporters **** off to his blog and he can post his calls there for you all to fawn over, as calls they, not trades. you will recall he refused to post proof of a trade as asked of him yesterday. that's not what ws wants though is it, no good preaching to the faithful when theres a board full of fresh clients to suck in here. i despair

 

[Lord Flasheart]

I don't know the firm very well but i see from the website that it's part of in the money stocks. The one thing that sticks out to me is that they think that Dax will be flying up by about 700 points before xmas. I'm watching this call because i believe it to be incorrect. Here's the pic from the wallstreet1928 blog:


http://api.ning.com/files/NTPFNk1hn...d45s8EzLoTdKSVdOoa*In/DAXPERFORMANCEINDEX.png

That is not a call,it is analysis. I have no problem with him charging for analyses if that's what he says he charges for,but he is making claims and needs to back them up so I am in favour of him proving himself this week with live calls at time of entry with volume and stops in place and indeed I wish him all the best. I do however feel t2win will have to make a stance if any of the same stuff comes up as in the last thread.

 

[Atilla]

I dunno 'bout that guy. Either he's for real and his ego just gets in the way of everything, or he's a fraud and his ego just gets in the way of everything.

I would have liked to see some genuine live calls, but he also did overstep his boundaries.

I'm neutral on this one.

I share this view that his ego gets in the way of everything.

He was given a chance and this probably went even further to his head with all the attention he has received. Not sure how a 2nd chance will save him.


Reminds me the likes of Rooney and Gaza - acceptional skill and talent but likely to get a red card in critical matches and lose the game altogether. Temperamental and imbalanced.

 

[Lightning McQueen]

That is not a call,it is analysis. I have no problem with him charging for analyses if that's what he says he charges for,but he is making claims and needs to back them up so I am in favour of him proving himself this week with live calls at time of entry with volume and stops in place and indeed I wish him all the best. I do however feel t2win will have to make a stance if any of the same stuff comes up as in the last thread.

looking at his blog, nearly all the content is someone elses market view from around the interwebs, strip that out, is there much left of his own work?

 

[brewski1984]

Surely he's had plenty of chances by now. Why don't you just give him £50 a month, make 500 points a week and all this is irrelevant.

 

[Lightning McQueen]

I share this view that his ego gets in the way of everything.

He was given a chance and this probably went even further to his head with all the attention he has received. Not sure how a 2nd chance will save him.


Reminds me the likes of Rooney and Gaza - acceptional skill and talent but likely to get a red card in critical matches and lose the game altogether. Temperamental and imbalanced.

well to be fair mate, this'll be technically his 5th chance (by my rough reckoning) if given another go. if he gets it, it may as well be a free for all for any spammer vendor to polute the boards. it's getting close to that now with cs, fxcm and prob others openly pushing site links now

 

[MajorDutch]

85% yes vote so far. Give the people what they want!

 

[pboyles]

No because his intention is to run a 'fund' scam like Jacko on FF.

 

[pboyles]

I share this view that his ego gets in the way of everything.

He was given a chance and this probably went even further to his head with all the attention he has received. Not sure how a 2nd chance will save him.


Reminds me the likes of Rooney and Gaza - acceptional skill and talent but likely to get a red card in critical matches and lose the game altogether. Temperamental and imbalanced.

Except of course that Gaza and Rooney didn't start each season saying they were going to score 500 goals...and then score 10, which is effectively what this clown did.

 

[new_trader]

85% yes vote so far. Give the people what they want!

WTF has happened to you MajorDutch? Mr 'No Brainer' has literally lost his brains and needs other people to make calls for him.

 

[Lightning McQueen]

i just seen a chart on his blog that is only available via a pay subscription service, the chart in question was not available in the public domain.

this begs the question, is ws peddling out analysis and trade calls that you can get from original sources? though ws subscription is offered slightly cheaper i admit but still wrong if that's going on.

 

[Lightning McQueen]

85% yes vote so far. Give the people what they want!

let the 85% go to his site and fill their boots, the rest of us are quite happy to miss out on his skills

 

[Atilla]

Except of course that Gaza and Rooney didn't start each season saying they were going to score 500 goals...and then score 10, which is effectively what this clown did.

hehe maybe not but the press, TV and their salaries led us to think and expect otherwise :cheesy:

Re your sharp comments though if you read Adverts I think you'll find they all talk up their features and benefits despite the Advertising watch dog looking over them.

Only the other day whilst skimming channels I saw medical professional touting some cream to remove wrinkles (honest guys skin cream is not something I'm into - just happened to be once in a blue moon that's all :cheesy

Clinically proven were the words used - which set me off on a few explitive expressions.

It's a business. Name of the game n all that.

Now we don't see you bouncing up and down about skin cream do we?

 

[new_trader]

WTF has happened to you MajorDutch? Mr 'No Brainer' has literally lost his brains and needs other people to make calls for him.

You needed to add a 'Couldn't care less' option because that is what I would vote, as I'm sure many others would as well. There is a huge difference between 'No', 'Don't care' and ignoring the poll altogether, your poll is giving a very distorted result.

 

[pboyles]

hehe maybe not but the press, TV and their salaries led us to think and expect otherwise :cheesy:

Re your sharp comments though if you read Adverts I think you'll find they all talk up their features and benefits despite the Advertising watch dog looking over them.

Only the other day whilst skimming channels I saw medical professional touting some cream to remove wrinkles (honest guys skin cream is not something I'm into - just happened to be once in a blue moon that's all :cheesy

Clinically proven were the words used - which set me off on a few explitive expressions.

It's a business. Name of the game n all that.

Now we don't see you bouncing up and down about skin cream do we?

Sounds like you tried it and it didn't work.

 

[dc2000]

Lets put it to the members. Give him a chance to post live calls this week if he steps out of line then ban him.

So you are seeking to over rule the mods in some sort of occupy T2W movment not many on this site have been given the huge leeway that was given to WS but he continued to abuse this

if you wish to see his analysis go to his web page its simple enough.

never ceases to amaze me how intelligent people who have been riped off always come up with an excuse for the defense of the perpatrator the berni madoff there were people saying he made some good calls but too many wanted a piece of the action and he was tempted to produce fake trades??

What WS was suggesting in his posts yesterday was and is simply illegal you can not do this without FSA authorisation nor can you solicit for the same ahead of FSA approval

 

[pboyles]

Look at the Jacko scam, people sent money, sometimes 20k or more, to a bank account in Hong Kong that didn't even have Jackos name on it. Did any of them care it was illegal? No because they thought they knew better. Then when he disappeared they were all moaning about the authorities doing nothing about it.