Bramble,
Hmm. Well I just dug it out and okay it isn't disgracefully awful, but at the time I learnt absolutely nothing new from it and fell for his propaganda that slates discretionary systems. Perhaps if it had been the first trading book I read I wouldn't have minded wasting fifty quid quite so much. There was some reasonable advice on psychology in it, I'll give him that, but otherwise just lots of wordy waffle and stuff that doesn't work.
Lazy, recycled vague information. Superfluity galore. Pointless long winded section on indicators that could be summed up in one line by "indicators work sometimes".
Most importantly, his mistaken and strong belief that there's no point trading anything except mechanical systems. This is seriously dangerous and bad advice. Ironically the book contains several that don't work, plagiarised from other people, accompanied by carefully selected backtests so it looks like they do.
"A hunch and a feeling are emotional. Although they may be based on some internal sense of logic, they are not sufficiently operational or mechanical for use by the day trader. Hence they must be discarded. They have no place in the repetoire of the day trader. Eliminate them from your bag of tricks. They will not serve you well."
Absolute rubbish. Intuition can often save one from taking or staying with a bad position. It is essentially pattern recognition. The subconscious is well worth listening to. Anyway trading doesn't have to be one or the other (all gut or all mechanical) and he misses this point entirely.