Why was author of best thread banned?

he was a multinick serial pest and a general nuisance with posting of lulz that caused widespread thread disruptions.

but other than that, seemed a likeable chap :)
 
Relatively speaking he didn't post child porn, didn't steal forum members money.
I would be very happy if he was allowed back. I think the bad influences he had have been banned for good.
 
elitejets said:
Relatively speaking he didn't post child porn, didn't steal forum members money.
I would be very happy if he was allowed back. I think the bad influences he had have been banned for good.
Click to expand...

If someone's thread is so good that it is better than commercial threads generating revenues , it would create a conflict with commercial interests.

It is like me selling stuff on the forum, which I don't,and taking interest away from sellers.

That would be a good reason to ban a good threat contributor.Conflict of interest.

O D T
 
elitejets said:
Can't you just let him back? I think its obvious now he wasn't the bad apple ...
Click to expand...

well he has been back two days and not caused a ripple yet, how long that will last is anyones guess, what you mean jets? not a bad apple? lol, "pool's closed" not ring any bells at all?

avatar260832_1.gif


something really just isn't right here, members are signing on that are barred full stop! i had the shock of my life yesterday to discover by accident that a certain bid a batty fellow has posted, another pixie loving chappy is very likely at large, amongst many others that are roaming the boards free, i despair sometimes i really do :(

btw has anyone seen options?
 
Lightning McQueen said:
well he has been back two days and not caused a ripple yet, how long that will last is anyones guess, what you mean jets? not a bad apple? lol, "pool's closed" not ring any bells at all?

avatar260832_1.gif


something really just isn't right here, members are signing on that are barred full stop! i had the shock of my life yesterday to discover by accident that a certain bid a batty fellow has posted, another pixie loving chappy is very likely at large, amongst many others that are roaming the boards free, i despair sometimes i really do :(
Click to expand...
If you don't know what's going on, then heaven help us mere mortals.

btw has anyone seen options?
Click to expand...

Good question; no. Where is he? I hope the strange cult / trading school (probably the same thing) he has been mixing with has not done him a mischief.
 
montmorencyt2w said:
If you don't know what's going on, then heaven help us mere mortals.

shh, i'm trying to feign surprise at all the new nicks talking to each other, to catch them off their guard ;)

Good question; no. Where is he? I hope the strange cult / trading school (probably the same thing) he has been mixing with has not done him a mischief.
Click to expand...

probably right now tied to a chair and gagged so as not to spill any beans :cheesy:
 
N Rothschild said:
whats the bet edgetrading is phill lol
Click to expand...

No, I'm not phil. But in light of his banning, I was just wondering whether or not it's worth reading his whole thread. I spent a lot of time following another thread, but the methodology failed to work for me, and I don't want to repeat the experience again. I'd therefore like to be confident a thread is worth reading and experimenting with, before beginning.
 
edgetrading said:
No, I'm not phil. But in light of his banning, I was just wondering whether or not it's worth reading his whole thread. I spent a lot of time following another thread, but the methodology failed to work for me, and I don't want to repeat the experience again. I'd therefore like to be confident a thread is worth reading and experimenting with, before beginning.
Click to expand...
Hi edgetrading,
I'm afraid I have some bad news for you. What you ask for is impossible. There is no 'one size fits all' thread with ideas or strategies that work for everyone. You have to take from each post on each thread that which sits with your view of the markets and complements your existing ideas and beliefs. There are no short cuts that I know of. Most important of all is to ignore the messenger and focus exclusively on the message alone. There are lots of excellent and worthwhile posts that have been written by people who have subsequently been banned. Equally, there are many posts that are complete rubbish written by long standing members who have a high post count and 'Legendary Member' by their name. I'm the author of a fair few of them! However, that's not to say that the only people worth listening to are those who have been banned! Like I say, the message is what matters, not the status of the messenger, be it banned, legendary or somewhere in between.
;)
Tim.
 
edgetrading said:
No, I'm not phil. But in light of his banning, I was just wondering whether or not it's worth reading his whole thread. I spent a lot of time following another thread, but the methodology failed to work for me, and I don't want to repeat the experience again. I'd therefore like to be confident a thread is worth reading and experimenting with, before beginning.
Click to expand...


If you like that sort of thing, then I think you'll find that it's the sort of thing you like (to probably misquote Mark Twain).

As I remember, his posts were usually very entertaining, although got a bit mad towards the end. I seem to remember that his trading style wouldn't have suited me, but you may find that it suits you.

It can be very instructive reading a long thread all the way through, and not just about trading.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Sharky
T2W Members' Choice Awards 2009 - Winners Announced!
Replies
9
Views
5K
dr.blix
dr.blix
dr.blix
Why was Wallstreet1928 not recognised in '09 MC Awards?
Replies
2
Views
1K
dr.blix
dr.blix
V
Why has the Thread been Removed ???
Replies
2
Views
2K
Grey1
Grey1
Sharky
  • Sticky
Featured T2W Best Threads
Replies
2
Views
5K
Sharky
Sharky
P
Deletion of threads!
4 5 6
Replies
113
Views
18K
mr_cassandra
mr_cassandra
Top