Peel my onion !
not bad .....but you have to be way down the learning pipe before this stuff makes a difference...dont worry about peeling your onion till you understand the complete insides and outs of Markets , Trading and your own system - then start the soul searching
most people think 3-6m is enough .....I say 10,000 hours
N
not bad .....but you have to be way down the learning pipe before this stuff makes a difference...dont worry about peeling your onion till you understand the complete insides and outs of Markets , Trading and your own system - then start the soul searching
most people think 3-6m is enough .....I say 10,000 hours
N
Re: Peel my onion !
I'm broadly in agreement with you, but I think there comes a stage where many people might have too, particularly those drawn to a more discretionary approach.
The problem is that psychology plays a part in every single aspect of the game, and that also includes the way we approach research, out beliefs about how markets operate, how we view a chart, our work ethic etc. I'd wager there are a great many people struggling even at these levels who may benefit from. A little self analysis and professional help
Im not sure this stuff is appropriate for discussion in public, and we are unlikely to get anyone to say very much anyway.
I'm broadly in agreement with you, but I think there comes a stage where many people might have too, particularly those drawn to a more discretionary approach.
The problem is that psychology plays a part in every single aspect of the game, and that also includes the way we approach research, out beliefs about how markets operate, how we view a chart, our work ethic etc. I'd wager there are a great many people struggling even at these levels who may benefit from. A little self analysis and professional help
Im not sure this stuff is appropriate for discussion in public, and we are unlikely to get anyone to say very much anyway.
Re: Peel my onion !
I would tend to disagree. In my view it is the complete opposite. There is nothing wrong with the markets, the problem lies with the people.
If they don't look inward they will never find the answer.
I would tend to disagree. In my view it is the complete opposite. There is nothing wrong with the markets, the problem lies with the people.
If they don't look inward they will never find the answer.
Last edited:
Re: Peel my onion !
Funny, the years tick by and the message is always the same..
Trading is without doubt a "blend" of psychology and skills.
Starting out for most people is without doubt better if the psychology part is in place to start with. All that is required is rock solid discipline and organisation.. thats all..
then the "market" skills follow... most people dont have any disipline, and they dont learn... ever
Funny, the years tick by and the message is always the same..
Trading is without doubt a "blend" of psychology and skills.
Starting out for most people is without doubt better if the psychology part is in place to start with. All that is required is rock solid discipline and organisation.. thats all..
then the "market" skills follow... most people dont have any disipline, and they dont learn... ever
Re: Peel my onion !
Well, just for fun, lets take this bit about how we view a chart.
The discretionary trader.
I'd say that the vast majority of single instrument monkeys have one chart on their screen...
ok so maybe as they get a little further down the line they decide that multiple time frame charts and more screens make the picture clearer....
even further down the line they decide that their chosen instrument would benefit from looking at correlation...
and so it goes on.
The point is...at any point in time..price can do one of three things, up, down, or sideways.
Might just as well toss a coin and hope for the best
Well, just for fun, lets take this bit about how we view a chart.
The discretionary trader.
I'd say that the vast majority of single instrument monkeys have one chart on their screen...
ok so maybe as they get a little further down the line they decide that multiple time frame charts and more screens make the picture clearer....
even further down the line they decide that their chosen instrument would benefit from looking at correlation...
and so it goes on.
The point is...at any point in time..price can do one of three things, up, down, or sideways.
Might just as well toss a coin and hope for the best
Re: Peel my onion !
Coin tossing will no more increase the chance of success in trading than in playing roulette. The odds are fixed in both, except the odds in trading is significantly lower. The only saving grace for trading is the unlimited nature of the reward. The reason some people win in the market over the long run is to do with the fact that they understand the reward and not because they know how to win more often.
The key to trading is to understand what is out there. No amount of psychological introspection or massaging will change the the odds on a roulette table. To focus on the psychology, which has no effect on the odds, is a waste of time.
Might just as well toss a coin and hope for the best
Coin tossing will no more increase the chance of success in trading than in playing roulette. The odds are fixed in both, except the odds in trading is significantly lower. The only saving grace for trading is the unlimited nature of the reward. The reason some people win in the market over the long run is to do with the fact that they understand the reward and not because they know how to win more often.
The key to trading is to understand what is out there. No amount of psychological introspection or massaging will change the the odds on a roulette table. To focus on the psychology, which has no effect on the odds, is a waste of time.
Last edited:
Re: Peel my onion !
Once again i have to disagree with you Joe. Everything one does has some degree of psychological involvement in it. Its just that in most cases your psyche is doing it subconsciously.
It is not about the odds but its how you handle them odds that makes all the difference. Therefore psychological introspection is no waste of time. If people traded just based on the odds or played roulette just based on the odds then they would all be losers. It is the fact that they can deal with winners and control their greed, or deal with losers and control not the next trade that makes all these games possible.
If you cannot handle the existing odds then the odds against you increase. How will you do this without focusing on the psychology aspect?
Once again i have to disagree with you Joe. Everything one does has some degree of psychological involvement in it. Its just that in most cases your psyche is doing it subconsciously.
It is not about the odds but its how you handle them odds that makes all the difference. Therefore psychological introspection is no waste of time. If people traded just based on the odds or played roulette just based on the odds then they would all be losers. It is the fact that they can deal with winners and control their greed, or deal with losers and control not the next trade that makes all these games possible.
If you cannot handle the existing odds then the odds against you increase. How will you do this without focusing on the psychology aspect?
Re: Peel my onion !
How silly would it sound if a loosing roulette player goes to a shrink and asks for help to improve his results ? Afterwards, the outcome is predictable, he will loose some more. The reason is he is supposed to loose, because he is put into a situation by someone to loose. Changing the player's psychology does not change the behaviour of that someone who put the player in a position to loose. The problem isn't the player, but that someone and what he does.
How silly would it sound if a loosing roulette player goes to a shrink and asks for help to improve his results ? Afterwards, the outcome is predictable, he will loose some more. The reason is he is supposed to loose, because he is put into a situation by someone to loose. Changing the player's psychology does not change the behaviour of that someone who put the player in a position to loose. The problem isn't the player, but that someone and what he does.
Re: Peel my onion !
“The reason is that a man may see straight and clearly and yet become impatient or doubtful when the market takes its time about doing as he figured it must do. That is why so many men in Wall Street, who are not at all in the sucker class, not even in the third grade, nevertheless lose money. The market does not beat them. They beat themselves, because though they have brains they cannot sit tight. Old Turkey was dead right in doing and saying what he did. He had not only the courage of his convictions but the intelligent patience to sit tight.”
Perhaps you can explain this then Joe.
“The reason is that a man may see straight and clearly and yet become impatient or doubtful when the market takes its time about doing as he figured it must do. That is why so many men in Wall Street, who are not at all in the sucker class, not even in the third grade, nevertheless lose money. The market does not beat them. They beat themselves, because though they have brains they cannot sit tight. Old Turkey was dead right in doing and saying what he did. He had not only the courage of his convictions but the intelligent patience to sit tight.”
Perhaps you can explain this then Joe.
Re: Peel my onion !
Quit easily. Those men spent too much time working on their psychology, and not enough time on studying what is out there and how things out there work. The inability to wait for the market is a sign of not understanding the market or having an insufficient understanding of the market. Working on the psychology of patience does not help in that situation because the market moves fast some of the time, and moves slow some other times. Being blindly patient is as big a looser as being blindly impatient. The key is to understand the market and apply a correct level of patience.
In actual fact, if you know what you are doing, patience is irrelevant. If the correct risk control is put into place, having an incorrect level of patience needn't kill you. So it is a question of technique and not psychology.
In trading, seeing is better than thinking. Therefore people need to work on their eyes and not their psychology - maybe getting a pair of glasses could work, or worth a try at least.
Quit easily. Those men spent too much time working on their psychology, and not enough time on studying what is out there and how things out there work. The inability to wait for the market is a sign of not understanding the market or having an insufficient understanding of the market. Working on the psychology of patience does not help in that situation because the market moves fast some of the time, and moves slow some other times. Being blindly patient is as big a looser as being blindly impatient. The key is to understand the market and apply a correct level of patience.
In actual fact, if you know what you are doing, patience is irrelevant. If the correct risk control is put into place, having an incorrect level of patience needn't kill you. So it is a question of technique and not psychology.
In trading, seeing is better than thinking. Therefore people need to work on their eyes and not their psychology - maybe getting a pair of glasses could work, or worth a try at least.
Last edited:
Re: Peel my onion !
The importance of knowing what you are doing cannot be overstated enough. But that is not an argument against the application of psychology.
Even if you do know precisely what you are doing it is a simple fact that you are still applying psychology, either consciously or subconsciously.
The very first thing that will strike you, if you completely understand the markets is the reasons why most traders fail and why most never get to that point.
Although the reason for this may be what you say, a complete understanding. Getting there is not achieved without a tough mental journey.
The importance of knowing what you are doing cannot be overstated enough. But that is not an argument against the application of psychology.
Even if you do know precisely what you are doing it is a simple fact that you are still applying psychology, either consciously or subconsciously.
The very first thing that will strike you, if you completely understand the markets is the reasons why most traders fail and why most never get to that point.
Although the reason for this may be what you say, a complete understanding. Getting there is not achieved without a tough mental journey.
Re: Peel my onion !
You should already know if you claim to completely know what you are doing.
If not ,well then thats for you to find out yourself.
You should already know if you claim to completely know what you are doing.
If not ,well then thats for you to find out yourself.
