In stocks buyers have the edge because markets trend upwards long term - bull markets last longer
than bear markets - In forex niether have the edge as being bearish on one currency = bullish on the other. Also it is said that 90% of traders lose but with money management you could lose 80% of your trades with a 4:1 risk reward ratio and still be in profit so have you really lost even though you have lost most of your trades?
I think that we both have different perceptions as to what "edge" means.
To me, "edge", even in forex, means the 10% that does win has it, not the 90% that does not.
A trader who loses most of his trades, does not have an edge, IMO.
By losing, I mean losing money as a result.
As far as shares are concerned, one can trade a very good rising share, even the index itself, and lose money consistently because of bad timing. Such a trader has no edge.
Having an edge means knowing how trade in such a way as to be, consistently successful. It may mean knowing only one company, the business that that company is in , trading its ups and downs on a regular basis and nothing wlse.
Split