Cablemonster did the numbers. Unfortunately for people like Phil, you can find a lot of things online these days, particularly if you have a company. And when you also make big claims, you can run into trouble.
You can find for example the address of a company. And if you find that someone is running a couple of companies, one of which made at minimum £250,000 in 2012 based on a claimed pip count and a one-lot minimum (surely he can stretch to more than a one-lot with his success), plus 50,000 at least in the last 3 months as you said, plus is taking a few thousand pounds a month from people signed up to the chat-room, and has been doing this sort of thing for several years, yet the company is based in a fairly small terraced house on a pretty average street in Liverpool, then you realise that someone somewhere is telling porkies.
Now all of this was obvious without doing any due dilligence, but since you're arguing, go and find the facts yourself. It's all there and freely available and it's all so bloody obvious.
I have nothing against Phil, aside from his behaviour here, which was rude, dismissive and dishonest. I'm sure you would like to think that I have an agenda against him, but I don't. I have no history with him, I wasn't around when he was a regular poster, I don't know him. He may even make a profit at trading. Don't know, don't care. That's his own business, makes no difference to me. I hope for his sake that he does.