Skim, what do you think of this?

stoploss please

Established member
780 10
Skim, what do you think of this

Hi Skim

I know you do not use indicators and only look at price action. Today, I looked at the charts as you would, via price action and and also via my beloved RSI.

I always have problems with consolidations. I know that they should break in the direction of the trend but self doubt can be a pain.

I have attached two graphs. The first one is purley the indicator and how I use it. The RSI was shouting at me go long on the flag break

The second chart is purley price action. I understand your probable short entry at the top but which bar would you have hit on the flag break out.

Cheers
Andy
 

Attachments

  • dowchart1.xls
    47 KB · Views: 557

ChartMan

Legendary member
5,580 46
Perfect. Just one thing, I'd do away with the INDU volume..It does nothing for you... S&P futs VOL is a different matter.
Sorry, Skim, I didn't mean to butt in, just got carried away.
 

Skimbleshanks

1
2,325 16
On your first chart, you will see a double top, and then a lower high - the break of this third top would be the ideal shorting place.

Once you see a lower low after the third high (actually it's the right shoulder of a head & shoulders), that is your short entry.

As Chartman says, don't bother with vol on the Dow - it is all the same height, and therefore meaningless (to me anyway). Use ES volume.

I find it easier to have all my bars the same colour - your eye is not distracted by the two colours and you can see the highs and lows easier.

On the Dow 5 min chart right now is an inverted head & shoulders being formed. I never want to be a 'told you so' but did you notice how well the inverted h&s worked at the end of yesterday that I annotated on the chart?

Now if you look on the big picture over the last couple of days, you will see an even bigger head & shoulders being formed. At the moment the right neckline is beneath the left neckline, therefore this is bearish.

So the inverted h&s at the end of today could just be the turning point for the right shoulder to form. But I try never to speculate, just trade what actually happens, when it happens, and not a moment before, or after - but it doesn't always happen like that!

Let me know if you don't understand, and I'll post a chart.
 

options

Senior member
2,374 218
If it's not too much trouble post away please Skimmy
 

Skimbleshanks

1
2,325 16
Yes, it's a lot of trouble, but as it's you asking, dear Options, I shall be delighted to rustle up a chart.

Just off to do some rustling ...
 

stoploss please

Established member
780 10
Skim

Thanks for this. You have got me thinking.

Chartman

I am now using channels on both price and the indicator. You are right about them being useful.

Can I just say that everyone on this site is Vhelpful.
 

Skimbleshanks

1
2,325 16
Finished rustling, and the following two charts are my efforts.

First, the big picture, showing three different sets of head & shoulders, two of which are inverted. There are others, but it just got too confusing to show them all.

The inverted h&s at the end of today suggests that we may get an up move tomorrow morning, to form the right shoulder of the big picture h&s.

Dow chart, 5 minutes:
 

Attachments

  • dow 8 oct big picture.jpg
    dow 8 oct big picture.jpg
    57.8 KB · Views: 1,100
  • Like
Reactions: wasp

Skimbleshanks

1
2,325 16
And now for the detailed small head & shoulders at the top of today's Dow.

You often get a h&s within a larger one, and they just unfold one by one.

The ideal short entry is just after the price has turned down after forming the 3rd hump, ie the right shoulder of the head & shoulders. At this position, you will know very soon if the trade is incorrect, and your stop will be hit. A very low risk trade.
 

Attachments

  • dow 8 oct.jpg
    dow 8 oct.jpg
    52.1 KB · Views: 1,023

ChartMan

Legendary member
5,580 46
And where else could you get an almost 10:1 R/R in a short space of time? Not that you knew it would go so low at the time.
 

Skimbleshanks

1
2,325 16
The best place to short, of course, would be on the first lower low of the double top, assuming you were able to hold the trade going against you for the right shoulder formation.

The trough between the 2nd and 3rd peaks is lower than the trough between the 1st and 2nd peaks, so that would have given you a good idea that by then the market was bearish.
 

stoploss please

Established member
780 10
Skim

There is small peak in between 1 and 2. Has this any significance. The reason I ask this is because recently, I watched a documentary about giant waves. The ones you find in the sea and not on a chart. Apparently these waves appear out of nowhere to sink ships. The reason why they exist is because the killer wave takes energy from the waves either side of it.

Going back to the chart, immediatley after the first peak, we have a small wave up. The way I see it, the second top should be able to draw on the unused energy from new longs that was not spent used on the previous small peak. The inability of the second top break the high of the first top after a feeble middle peak also reinforced a bearish stance.

Does this make sense. I'm confusing myself now.
 
 
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

But it's thanks to our sponsors that access to Trade2Win remains free for all. By viewing our ads you help us pay our bills, so please support the site and disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock