What was the final verdict on James16 ?
Would appreciate a precis of opinion. i am aware of approach etc
Don't think there ever is a final verdict unless they've been found out somehow.
He's not the worst I've seen. My impression from what I have seen is:
Has some understanding of price movement - Good
He advocates demoing first - Good
He advocates longer timeframes - Good and Bad (massive stops)
He suggests a place for stop, so risk is somewhat covered - Good
He doesn't discuss exits for profit or trade management - Bad
He doesn't really discuss context - Bad
He doesn't really discuss trend - Bad
He has never made any live calls or proved he can trade and charges for a website - Make your own mind up
There seem to be dozens of James16 followers all with their own variation of entries, but the reason for my comment above is that almost all of them seem to not even mention what I consider the most important parts to this, longer term trend, context (trend is part of context, but I mean more than that), cutting losers and running winners (i.e. trade management), and without those it's not very useful or testable. Just dozens of followers fiddling around with entries that don't really matter in the big scheme. But that's normal I suppose, nobody really wants to talk about the things that matter. All imho.