(trying hard to cut back my posts: one of my New Year Resolutions)
LF: you need to just believe in Old Ma, and focus on improving that.
BS has posted many trades, albeit in hindsight.
However, he has dropped enough hints as to his methods.
He "appears" to use pivots. Look at all his trades and see when/if the entries/exits tally with pivots.
He also talks about swing-trading. Have you tried looking at weekly pivots as potential trades?
(I'm not convinced he randomly enters(!), but appears to trade range-breaks and targets nearest pivot?)
Sorry to sound metaphysical, but whether BS is profitable or not is irrelevant, it's whether his "well founded and thought out opinion" makes sense to you, and whether you can internalise components into your own trading.
Actually, if you show interest, with intelligent and positive responses, he may decide to offer a place at his trading arcade, when it opens.
![Wink ;) ;)]()
(not that your responses are anything less than intelligent; or positive)
Hope you Christmas traders made some extras. I am out till January.
(have been trialling HA-bars and pivots, with mixed results)