Direct access brokers vs Online brokers

PeterB

Member
82 1
I am currently only trading on paper and have been doing for the last 18 months and at long last have decided,now to take the plunge and trade with real money.I am currently reading Tools and Tactics for the Master day trader by Mr Velez and Capra founders of Pristine.Com.They talk about the advantages and disadvantages of Direct access brokers and Online brokers.My question is to those of you who trade is there any advantage nowadays of using a direct access broker as opposed to say using Ameritrate an online broker.Ameritrade offers Nasdaq level 2 and competitive rates.The above mentioned book went to print in the year 2000.
 

bkbigfish

Junior member
15 2
I use direct access, as do most day or short-term traders, simply because of the commissions and execution speed. An online broker forces you to route the order through their servers, which then send it to their trade desk, which then executes it. A direct access broker gives you a direct line to the exchange; when you enter an order, you can almost instantly see it show up in the bid or ask. It's maybe only a few seconds faster, but in volatile markets it can be a huge difference.

The best online broker commissions I've seen are all about $5 per trade minimum. Interactive brokers charge $.005 (half a penny) per share, with a $1.00 minimum, while MB Trading and others charge $0.01 per share with a $1.00 minimum.

The commission and execution differences are not that important if you trade infrequently, but if you trade at least once a day, in and out, you save at least $8 - and of course a day trader making 10 trades or more a day would save $80 or more. I don't have any statistics on execution, but direct access brokers must almost certainly, because they're direct, offer better executions.

Lastly, this may not be relevant as much these days, but in the older days of the Internet when connections weren't as reliable, several veteran traders I've read about swore off of online brokers because connections would frequently go out. Of course, this can happen with a direct access broker, but I haven't heard any horror stories about them. Many (I'd say most, but I don't know for sure) serious traders use direct access. Day traders certainly do.

I don't know why people use online brokers. I can only think that it's for the research (which is of dubious quality in the first place), and because they outspend in advertising by an enormous amount.

If anyone suggests an online broker, ask why.
 

notouch

Member
98 2
What's an example of a direct access broker? Interactive Brokers defines itself at direct access but you clearly mean something different.
 
 
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

But it's thanks to our sponsors that access to Trade2Win remains free for all. By viewing our ads you help us pay our bills, so please support the site and disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock