Worst EA = Best signal provider?

[FredCaires]

Everybody says that EAS don't work, there are even EA that will dry your account balance in a month. So here is my idea, if you have the worst EA and with that EA you loose more than 90 % of the times that means you win 10 %, theoretically means that if you trade against the EA you will have 90 % winner trades and 10 % loss, you can't have a scalping ea cause they don't fail in guessing the markets move and they close positions in a loss even when afterward the market moves in the right direction however if you have an EA that as a take profit of around 50 pips or 100 pips that means that the EA fails in guessing the market directions so if you trade against the EA you will trade in the correct direction. Market can only go two ways, up or down. EA buys, you sell, EA sells, you buy.

What do you think?

 

[zupcon]

Here we go again...

 

[FredCaires]

Here we go again...

Did anyone already tried it?
Doesn't work?
I had a metatrader demo account in which an EA lost 100 000 dollars with 0.1 lot trades. In 100 the EA could only win 5 or 9 trades.

 

[Hotch]

Doesn't work?

Bingo

 

[FredCaires]

Bingo

Can i bother you to ask why?
Not saying you're wrong, i just want to know why it doesn't work, sorry.

 

[Hotch]

Can always bother to ask, just whether you'll get a response .

Commission and slippage is a big one. Then if the system doesn't have equal buy and stop distances, then it won't simple be that a loss is a win etc.

If it had buy conditions and equal stop distance of 50 pts, then reversing it most likely would work, but the majority of things that don't work aren't like this.