Yeah but on 2 occasions i have explained that trading off 5m candles and holding for a couple of minutes is not swing trading and that holding from 1 - 4 days is in fact swing trading, i even sent him a link with definitions of swing/ intraday etc and also some e-books that it seems he's not bothered reading.. and he's still looking for an indicator to make him a successful trader, not being funny with anyone but it seems like people come on and expect to become great traders with zero effort