Dispatches from the Front

Alex and I were just in Vegas speaking at a seminar for the Traders' Expo. The room was silent and tumbleweed went by as topics such as mental discipline, money management and psychology were discussed. The slides switched to the trading setups and instantly the whole crowd perked up like watching an accident happen in real time on the highway. They wanted to know "does this guru have the holy grail??" What they do not realize is the first "boring" part of the seminar is the holy grail.

Geoff
 
The average man does not like uncertainties. He is not trained to cope with them. He will try to “sweep them under the rug.” He will use any device that will make it possible for him to feel “more sure,” for he is not willing to accept a “maybe” or an “I don’t know” as an answer.

And so he will resort to averages, to market indicators, to complicated charts of intersecting lines designed to prove that “it” is either a Bull Market or a Bear Market. He will accept almost any kind of nonsense if it is stated with enough assurance. He will buy horoscopes to determine the trend of the market by the position of the planets. If all else fails, he will look for some authority who will relieve him of using his own intelligence, by making the either/or decisions for him. But he must have a straight, simple answer; otherwise it means nothing to him.

Do you see how this way of looking at things is out of line with the facts? Do you see how it leads, inevitably, to frustration, anxiety, and demoralization?

It is asking too much of reality. It is setting up a make-believe world, and then crying if the world isn’t exactly like the make-believe.

We know, for instance, that trees “in general” are round. But you have seen tree trunks distorted by a cramped location, or by the trunks of adjacent trees, that are not round at all. It is useful to know that “tree trunks are round,” only so long as we understand that this is an abstraction, and the reality in any particular case has to be looked at, and if it is not round, that is that; the territory is the final answer, not our “map.”

John Magee
 
About posting charts.

The standard complaint is that message boards are all theory and no practice. All thought and no action. Let's post "real" charts (like a chart that's a day old is any different from a chart that's a week old, or a month old) and talk about them. So somebody posts a chart and nobody says anything, including the individual who pressed for posting the charts in the first place. This naturally discourages the person who posted the chart and he stops posting them, and nobody else picks up the slack. And you're back where you started.

What inexperienced traders miss is that we trade not the markets but our perceptions of the markets. When A looks at a chart, he sees something different than B does because he's looking for different things. And if B has no idea what A is looking for or why he's looking for it, there's not much to say unless he interprets it in his own way, which is generally of interest only to someone who hasn't a clue and is looking to borrow somebody else's strategy and tactics.

Therefore, if one wants to post a chart to illustrate some point, then that's a public service and always welcomed. However, if one is seeking comment on the chart, then he must explain what it is he's trying to do and why he's trying to do it. Otherwise, whoever looks at the chart is forced to interpret it based on what he himself is looking for, which may have no pertinence to what the poster is looking for.

Therefore, anyone looking for anything substantive should explain his strategy and tactics so that others can say something intelligent. Otherwise, whatever comments are made are likely to be along the lines of "nice chart". If one doesn't want to do that, I see no reason to post a chart other than to illustrate a point, as mentioned above. In that case, no comment is expected, and no one's feelings are hurt if none is forthcoming.
 
A simple way to be a better trader

Trade less. A lot less. Its that simple.

The biggest problem that most traders make is taking profits too quickly. This leads to overtrading. Some market dunces have quaint sayings like " you never go broke taking a profit. " That is just bs. If you take profits too quickly, you will go nowhere in this business.

Trading less is closely related to the one thing people need to do. Sit. And watch and wait. Wait some more and keep waiting. Being selective in one's trades is a way to reduce trading, have longer time frames, and keep losses small because the entry will by nature be good because of your selectivity. Good entries allow fairly tight stops with big price targets providing a good risk reward ratio. I am assuming that one has had some success trading and has a winning system or discretionary method.

Look over your trades and see which ones have made you money and which ones have lost you money. The few best trades and trade ideas likely provided most if not all of the profits on your trading.
 
Top