I'm not sure what the solution is. I don't dispute Sharky's right to make this a commercial venture, I just can't see it sustainable in it's current format. And tbh, if, somewhere, there was a forum that had a higher proportion of serious traders on it (not necessarily wholesale IB / hedge fund / prop people, just not newbs asking daft questions about forex robots and 1 minute cable charts), I would probably be happily ensconced there by now. I just happen to have gotten into the habit of posting here over the years, mostly because, unlike Moneytec (which I was a member of for years), it is, or at least was, UK focused (which I prefer, despite the good contributions of some notable overseas members)