Psychology

Managing Emotions While Trading

Integrating Left Brain and Right Brain Thinking for Balanced Trading

Trading seems so easy on the surface. Traders, while learning a methodology, are told (and believe), “Just follow the rules of your methodology and trading plan and you are on your way to achieving your dreams. Oh, and by the way, keep your emotions in check.”

This little add-on after-thought, “just keep your emotions in check”, comes to haunt nearly every trader until they learn to master and learn from their emotions. Curiously the highly left brained orientation (logical problem solving skill sets) of trader educational systems blind both educators and traders to the influence that our right brain (our emotional brain) has over a trader?s capacity to think effectively – and consequently the success of a person?s trading.

The flaw is simple and counter intuitive to the rationalistic lens through which we view the world. Particularly given a trader?s bias to find predictable certainty in the market. We get stuck in a way of viewing the world that believes, on a basic level, that if we really know the causal rules that logically govern the market, then we will succeed. This mindset depends on the existence of a set of rules “out there” that, once found, will be the Holy Grail of trading success. This is the essence of left brain thinking.

What neuro-science has discovered, however, turns our understanding of thinking and states of mind on its head. That seismic shift is this: The kind of thinking that a trader?s mind produces (for better or worse) comes out of the emotional state of the trader. And that is what influences the world that the trader sees and reacts to. There is no world “out there” that is deterministic – the world the trader sees is colored by the mindset of the trader who observes the world. And this is where traders get in trouble.

All thinking is emotional state dependent

Thought and state of mind follow emotion. Emotion does not follow thought. You trigger to emotion based on a disruption of an established familiar pattern. Then you begin thinking and reasoning from this emotional cloud. How can that be? It does not sound rational at all. And it?s not. It means we create our understanding of our world from our adaptations to our deepest fears and desires.

Take the housing bubble fiasco as an example. After the housing market blew up many observers began examining just how lenders could have possibly thought that they could loan money for houses to people who could not afford to pay back the loans. In fact, these people were incapable of making even the first loan payment. Yet, the house of cards continued to build. Everybody was doing it and nobody “saw” there was a problem. The entire industry never saw the disaster coming. When it blew up, they were surprised. But other people, who had not been sucked into the delusional thinking that comes from greed (fear of missing out), saw it coming and bet against it. They were not surprised. Very bright people were seduced by greed, and in the mindset that came out of greed, they became blind to the long term consequences of the short term nature of the emotion of greed. They became drunk on greed and their thinking was compromised.

What does this look like in trading? Most traders actually lose before their trading day begins. They enter their day already in a cloud of fear. (Most will have pushed the awareness of this fear out of their mind so they can avoid dealing with it – which is the biggest mistake the trader can make.) From this state of fear, their right brain?s biological wiring for negative appraisal biases their evaluation of trading opportunities. The emotion ramps up, seizes any semblance of impartial evaluation of the trade, and either the trader jumps in impulsively to avoid having to endure even more fear or he stays on the side line of the trade, waiting for more confirmation, until the opportunity passes.

And here is the kicker. When the trader goes back to review his trades, he looks at his trades incredulously and asks, “What was I thinking? I know how to trade – how could I have possibly made such a stupid decision?” The difference between the thinking from which he later evaluates his trading day and the thinking that drove his trading during heat of the trade is his emotional state.

Even before he started his trading day, his thinking was corrupted by fear. Out of his emotional state of fear came the mindset that evaluated the market. That mindset saw danger, not opportunity. That mindset blinded him to his risk management skills, and, instead, focused his attention on the avoidance of fear. Out of that, he acted irrationally and made decisions not consistent with his trading plan.

Then, after his trading day was over and he was in a calm state of mind, he reviews his trades and could not understand what possessed him to trade so foolishly. In his rationally (that?s an emotional state just like fear) trained mind (read bias toward the left brain), he can execute trades with confidence and consistency. Unfortunately, not being able to regulate his emotions, the trader does not know how to manage his emotional equilibrium in the heat of battle. This is exactly why the military trains their soldiers in conditions that resemble the chaos of battle where the fear of death is a real and present danger. They train soldiers to the clear-headed thinking that is needed for the emotional state of fear and its management. Traders need to train in a similar way.

The First Step to Emotional State Management

People do not have an effective understanding of what an emotion is and what it does. Until a trader grasps the power an emotion has over thought, particularly fear and greed, the door to understanding and managing his emotional nature will remain elusive and cannot be opened.

First, emotions are biological in nature and take over our psychology. They are not part of our psychology, but rather they are biological. They shape our psychology (our perception of the world). Fear, in particular, is the most primitive of our emotions. It is the mother of biologic survival. That is why a trader must learn how to manage fear, or it will continue to overwhelm the impartial, disciplined, patient, and courageous kind of thinking upon which successful trading is built. Though fear will never be eliminated from a trader?s psychology, its intensity can be regulated so that it does not sweep the mind away in a cascade of negative thinking that leads to catastrophic results. Once managed, fear can be directed to help build an effective methodology for risk management. This requires left brain and right brain integration.

The problem with most traders is that they attempt to push fear aside or ignore it. This certainly can be done on a short term basis, but as the trader has draw-downs on his trading account, it becomes clear that avoiding his fears in trading cannot be sustained successfully long term.

Traders must learn to honor their internal struggle with their fears. To do this, the fear must be approached – not avoided (hesitating to entering trades) or attacked (impulsive trading). When the trader approaches his fears and learns from them, he (or she) opens the opportunity to re-organize himself into a more effective trader.

Basic emotional state management principles apply here. Your body, your brain, and your mind have to be calmed to begin this process. Otherwise the chemical nature of fear in the body will quickly reach high levels of arousal and will hijack the trader?s capacity to maintain a calm state of mind. (Just ask any trader who has experienced the fear of pulling the trigger.) To interrupt this process, traders will need to learn to volitionally breathe diaphragmatically. This long slow style of breathing impacts the heart rate which is connected to the “fight or flight” response that is part of our primitive survival brain. Without interrupting the arousal of an emotion with this kind of deep slow breathing, the trader, in effect, is adding gasoline on the fire of an emotion – particularly fear. If not managed, the emotion will explode and take over thinking. Suddenly the trader has self doubt, second guessing his decisions, and is seized by fear. With diaphragmatic breathing, you choke the emotional fire and return to a state of calm.

This is not the “cure” to compromised thinking. It is the first aid relief of an emotional hijacking – much like an emergency room physician is going to first stop the bleeding before the real problem is addressed. The calmness releases tension from the body, which in turn helps slow down thinking. A calmer mind is necessary to develop the powerful skills of discipline, patience, impartiality, and courage that are so important to peak performance trading. This is where the trader?s state of mind for peak performance can be developed.

Mindfulness – the Second Step to a Peak Performance Trading Mindset

Getting your body, brain, and mind calm does not solve the problem of creating a performance state of mind for traders. However it does provide the trader skills and tools for the first level of emotional state management. Next you have to wake up from your mindlessness. You need to develop an awareness of the thoughts in your mind and begin to examine them. You have to become an observer of the thoughts in the mind, rather than blindly drifting wherever your thoughts take you.

What does that mean? Let?s use an example to illustrate. Imagine being in front of your computer screens waiting for a set up to appear. You are waiting with anticipation as several possibilities emerge. You watch as the possible trade approaches the entry point. Now it is at the entry point and you find yourself looking for confirmation and more confirmation. Tune into the conversation in your mind as you watch this trade. “Should I take this trade? What if I?m wrong? I need a little more confirmation before I pull the trigger! It?s here; pull the trigger before this one slips by? Are you sure?”

Have you ever found yourself in this type of internal conversation? If you are not lying to yourself (mindlessness) – then sure you have. In this case though, you are being asked to be mindful of your thoughts rather than to be swept away by them without observing them. Without training, most of us get swept away into this line of thinking without ever waking up to the activity going on in our mind. This is called mindlessness. And it produces disastrous trading results. Being mindless while trading is a set up for failure.

In mindlessness, the trader becomes blind to the thinking going on in his mind. And in that blindness, the trader is consumed by these emotionally charged thoughts. He or she may not even notice the thoughts or may believe that “they are only my thoughts”. Becoming mindful of your thoughts takes away the power of the streams of thoughts to simply hijack your mind and take you to wherever they are going. In trading, mindlessness leads to poor trading results.

With applied mindfulness training specifically for trading, the trader becomes a witness to his internal thoughts rather than a blind victim. This “thinking” that you have now become mindful of can now be examined. What you learn in the development of mindfulness is that you and your thoughts are not the same. In fact, a more powerful question arises. Where do these thoughts come from?

We Trade Our Psychology – Our Unseen Beliefs and Biases

In the detached, calm assertive nature of mindfulness, we come to realize that thoughts are manifestations of our deepest beliefs and biases about ourselves, our worth, our (in)adequacy, and our power to influence our world. It is this core material that we have to re-organize to become peak performance traders.

Most traders avoid this necessary internal inspection of themselves and their deepest beliefs about who they are in the world. It causes short term discomfort, so our biology triggers us automatically to avoid the discomfort – the threat. It is all exposed in trading though. In fact, it is inescapable. In trading there is no place to hide from our deepest fears for long – it shows up their trading behavior and in their trading accounts. They manifest in the conversations (our thoughts) while in the midst of trading decisions. Until we develop the emotional intelligence to face our fears and learn from them, the trader will continue to produce mediocrity and draw downs to his or her trading account.

By calming the fear to a tolerable level, the trader can approach their own personal demons that keep them from organizing themselves into a peak performance trader. In mindfulness, we learn to separate our identity from the historical beliefs that we were born into. A powerful possibility occurs here. Freed from the power of our fears, we can rediscover much more powerful meaning and purpose in our lives. And from this deeper sense of self, the trader establishes the discipline, the patience, the confidence, the impartiality, and courage to change him or herself and become the peak performance trader living within.

This aspect of developing your trader?s state of mind can be called the re-invention of the self or the re-organization of the self. Emotional regulation leads the trader to a stability where he can sit with his fears and resolve them – rather than avoiding them. In applied mindfulness training, the trader develops the skills of separating his identity from his thought life. With further development, the trader begins to direct his attention mindfully and brings into the light of his awareness the discipline, confidence, impartiality, patience, and courage that are needed to blossom into a peak performance trader.

This is the internal struggle that goes on within every trader. This is the process of knowing the self and conquering your fears. The outcome is a much more purposeful, meaningful, and joyful life. As an added benefit, the trader develops a peak performance state of mind. And it begins by equipping yourself to embrace your deepest emotions and fears that manifest in your trading. With an open mind, you become what you were born to be. And trading is your teacher.

J. Rande Howell, can be contacted at Traders State of Mind

Rande Howell (MEd, LPC) helps traders develop a peak performance state of mind.  He is both a licensed therapist and performance coach whose work is grounded in emotional regulation, mindfulness, and Jungian archetypes applied to trading.  He has a clinical background in training people to master their emotions and to transform self-limiting beliefs into productive mindsets.  Rande's work centers on how to break the fear-based beliefs that imprison a trader’s performance and that block the development of a trader’s potential to achieve financial and personal dreams. By learning how to manage the biology of emotion, real and long lasting changes can then be made to the mind’s core beliefs from which the trader engages the uncertainty, risk, and probability that must be mastered in trading.  He is the author of four books including Mindful Trading: Mastering Your Emotions and the Inner Game of Trading.

Rande Howell (MEd, LPC) helps traders develop a peak performance state of mind.  He is both a licensed therapist and performance coach whose work...

shadowninja

Legendary member
5,524 642
Pretty good article... but many of the principles are stolen from Buddhism. If people apply said principles in life, not just trading, then they will be happier. Not that this is necessary - I mean, we're all happy deep down, right, so who needs Buddhism? ;)
 

zsawevv212

Member
60 2
emotion is a very important factor that will affect your business .this article is good teaching how to control your emotion
 

Rande Howell

Member
51 7
Pretty good article... but many of the principles are stolen from Buddhism. If people apply said principles in life, not just trading, then they will be happier. Not that this is necessary - I mean, we're all happy deep down, right, so who needs Buddhism? ;)
Mindfulness is a tool that is rooted in many different traditions -- not just Buddhism. The point is to develop the skill of stepping back from your pre-conceived notions, your biases, and your automatic assessments and recognize they are not you. They represent only one possible organization of who you can be. Because our brains adapt us to certain ways of perceiving the world and lock us in to self limiting patterns, traders discover rapidly that they must deconstruct their historical way of interpreting the world if they are to become successful in trading.
Applying "if principles" is useless until you can regulate, not eliminate, emotion. Your biology has far more influence over your capacity to think than most realize. Until you learn to manage your biology, you will never be able to consistently manage the state of mind that you bring to trading.
 

ian23

Active member
179 9
For emotions in trading i can offer this: Trade the right size, if risk to much you will be over emotional and cant think straight and we all know what happens when you risked too much and the market goes against you. Do not risk to little either cause you may feel unconcerned if the market moves against you and end up not managing the trade the way should have.

I learned both these the hard way. First one leads to blow out and the second one leads to developing a pattern of bad habits and possibly a draw down that can get you in a position that you constantly have to battle the first one when your account gets to small.
 

15 min tlb

Senior member
2,057 98
We've just published a new T2W article called "Managing Emotions While Trading " by Rande Howell.

Quick Summary: Rande Howell discusses trading psychology and why a trader's thinking often follows their emotions and how Emotional State Management can help in achieving a Peak Performance Trading Mindset

PS. Don't forget to rate the article after you've read it and share your comments on this thread.
I generally don't compliment people , but Rande knows his stuff .Brilliant lecture.

Mastering Fear by Developing Internal Discipline - Rande Howell - YouTube
 

Rande Howell

Member
51 7
I try to keep detached from my emotions when it comes to trading, I just stick to my routine and execute it the way I planned. Emotions make me deviate from my plan and I tend to lose more when my emotions come in to play. It was really hard for me to not let my emotions dictate my actions but in time, it got a lot easier.
It's not that you quit having emotions while trading. That's impossible. Emotions are biological and are required to produce action of any kind. What you learned to do is to become an a better comsumer of emotion. Impartiality, what most consider to be the absense of emotion, is in fact an emotional state that leads to the kind of thinking that is coveted in trading.

Rande Howell
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Shakone

Senior member
2,458 665
Can you go into more detail regarding why emotions are unavoidable. I don't really understand that emotions are biological. To me they seem to be reactions to some incoming stimulus that has been processed in some way and produced a biological response, i.e. if you could alter how the stimulus is processed, you could alter the biological response. Is this incorrect?
 

Rande Howell

Member
51 7
Can you go into more detail regarding why emotions are unavoidable. I don't really understand that emotions are biological. To me they seem to be reactions to some incoming stimulus that has been processed in some way and produced a biological response, i.e. if you could alter how the stimulus is processed, you could alter the biological response. Is this incorrect?
I encourage you to read Emotional Intelligence by Goleman. It will give you a basis in a modern understanding of emotion and cognition. Many people stay stuck in an emotion call rational (I can it impartiality) and can not see that rational is simply an emotion, not the absence of emotion.

Rande Howell
 

neil

Legendary member
5,167 745
Trading is a difficult thing that can be done only with an open mind. But if you don't conrol over your emotios and feelings, it will be more difficlut that way. If one is not feeling good, he must not be trading that day ! trading with an annoyed mode leads to loss. <span>As the loss continues to stack against us, that stress becomes more and more profound; making the concept of taking action even more intimidating. </span>
You are a student and a coach/trainer according to your details. So - what can you teach a trader?

And why do you cut material from other peoples posts and display them here as a product of your own expertise. If you do not state from where you got that material and who wrote it, then thats Plagiarism (cheating and misleading the reader into thinking you are an expert).
This is the post from which you extracted material to present as your own expertise :
How to Manage the Emotions of Trading | DailyFX

If you have a Vendor badge then people think you know what you are writing about. But if you cut and paste other peoples material without acknowledging same, then people might think that you act as a student might when cheating at essay writing.

(n)

Update...Oh- where did he go ?
A Mod strike maybe:)
 

Rande Howell

Member
51 7
Neil
Not sure who you are responding to. My name is Rande Howell, not Sidra. And certainly I did not write the article in FXDaily. But this is a trail on an article I did submit here. However, I've noticed that my articles are printed elsewhere with and without my permission. I find materials I've written sliced and diced verbatim from my writing all over the Internet. And I find them translated into different languages. This is simply part of the Internet.

Rande Howell