Should The Potential Setups 2 thread be closed?

[aspex]

re closing the previous thread.
I cannot believe that the small influence that traders here might have would affect a multi-trillion market if it is as big as we are told.
NO. td just got tired of being here so he has gone off to make some real money rather than put up with the ignorance of our lot.
You cannot blame him.

 

[Technically Fundamental]

4 pages, numerous conspiracies and zero set ups. We're doing great without TD. Anyone know what Elite is like?

 

[Technically Fundamental]

Anyone have an explanation as to why TD said nobody should open a copycat thread?

 

[sebby2468]

The J16 thread is still going on forex factory,which is where potential set-ups derived from,for those that want to take a look.

 

[Rossini]

Because if he felt that the first thread should be closed down then obviously a copy cat thread would have exactly the same affect as keeping the first one open. Why are you so bothered?

 

[Technically Fundamental]

I'm curious as to the reasoning behind this whole fiasco. I want to know who doesnt have "our best interests at heart". And if this thread is a good idea given the fact that he closed the other one.

 

[rawrschach]

Then instead of spamming, PM him, and if you don't think it's a good idea, don't participate.

 

[Technically Fundamental]

im not saying the boys in the pit dont go stop hunting on a nice quiet afternoon..but readin trade2win to do this? come on...you dont need to read a forum to work out where the non-pros are positioned..half the guys in the pit see most of the order flow anyway and can make extremely well educated guesses to where stops are anyway

So is dante saying t2w is a poor mans order flow?

 

[chilltrader]

The J16 thread is still going on forex factory,which is where potential set-ups derived from,for those that want to take a look.

Good idea.

I'm moving over to Forex Factory.

This is probably my last post on the forum.

Thanks all you lovely traders who helped me a lot (you know who you are )
- although most of you have gone now

Cheerio and good luck to all !!
:clap:

 

[cr6196]

i dont understand why people at a bank wud do that anyway, they can see the order book...why wud they need to look on an internet forum...

 

[goatse]

I didn't think bbmac posted his entries or exits?

 

[teojh]

boring.. is there another interesting and active thread that can replace potential setups?

 

[foredog]

boring.. is there another interesting and active thread that can replace potential setups?

Obvious f**k ups?

 

[poborsky]

shhhhhh...there watching!

ok got to go now........

YouTube - Fawlty Towers 106 end clip

 

[teojh]

great. lets post fake potential setups and fade the dealers.

 

[poborsky]

great. lets post fake potential setups and fade the dealers.

That thread has just been closed.

 

[N Rothschild]

oh btw, for anyone intresteded..

dante has blown his account....woops

 

[JRP2891]

oh btw, for anyone intresteded..

dante has blown his account....woops

Where'd you hear about that?

 

[trendie]

oh btw, for anyone intresteded..

dante has blown his account....woops

say it aint so.
how did you find out?
did he blow the account due to trading his set-ups?
OR, blow the account due to getting greedy with his percentage of capital risked?

they are two separate aspects.
if the former, then no MM will save you.
if the latter, then pin-bar set-ups are still profitable, but only when relevant MM used.
(there is a difference)

I cant believe its failure of set-ups, otherwise the original thread would have died out much, much, sooner.

you have set the gossip mill turning for this weekend, Genics! :cheesy:

EDIT: if what you say is true, then it must have been risking too much, since the original james16 is still running, from which TD based his stuff on.

 

[arabianights]

Tis true.

Why is my elbow grazed?