Re: Greek Debt Crisis Simplified Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBramble Of course, convergence could also be achieved by going in the other direction too. |
As to convergence, you're correct, without a doubt. Convergence is achieved by making richer states poorer and poorer states richer. Again, it's really all about whether you believe the intangible benefits are worth it. For both the convergence argument and for the fringe benefits, I am pretty sure that the one precedent we have, i.e. the US, suggests that it's all worth it in the end. In fact, if you look at American history, it's amazing how many parallels you find. For example, the states did face a very similar situation that the EU is facing now and, funnily enough, as one of the results of the bargain reached the capital of the US is Washington, rather than New York. Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBramble As a corollary to the above, I can’t help feeling a little bemused at the concept of increasing wealth in poorer nation states by giving them money with the intent they buy stuff from the existing manufacturing base of the (relatively wealthy) producer states, when they quite sensibly decide to use their free (cheap is more politically correct, but free is more realistic in inflationary and risk terms) money to enhance their own infrastructure and manufacturing capacity in order to offer significant competition to the same groups they were ‘supposed’ to be buying from. |
Well, that would actually be OK, because, as long as you're in the same boat and everyone plays by the rules, there's hope that there's enough pie for everyone to get a slice. It's the whole idea that trade, in general, is good for everyone in the long run and the more of it and the freer it is the better. To be sure, in all this, Greece is a special case, 'cause, quite clearly, they didn't do any of what you describe above.
__________________ "Insofar as I may be heard by anything, which may or may not care what I say, I ask, if it matters, that you be forgiven for anything you may have done or failed to do which requires forgiveness." |