Which would you trade?

JonnyT

Senior member
2,560 22
Both systems trade the EUR/USD and these are the results for the December 2003 contract, maximum of 1 trade per day entirely mechanical.

System A:

Win 30
Win % 48.39
Avg Win 0.00422
Lose 32
Lose % 51.61
Avg Lose 0.001590625
Total 0.0757
Equity High 0.0757

Max Draw 0.0124
Max Draw Date 17/11/2003

Profit Factor 2.653045187




System B:

Win 18
Win % 29.03
Avg Win 0.005072222
Lose 44
Lose % 70.97
Avg Lose 0.000481818
Total 0.0701
Equity High 0.0701

Max Draw 0.0053
Max Draw Date 12/11/2003

Profit Factor 10.52725367


The systems are based on the same entry.

Thoughts?

JonnyT
 

darrenf

Well-known member
481 3
I would say system B as it produces similar profit with lower drawdown. This is despite a lower win percentage.

Is this due to some sort of time stop. ie trade closed after x bars if not yet showing x profit?

I imagine system B would also allow more time to adjust if it starts to go wrong, without losing as much as sytem A would in the same circumstances.

Is this based on your early morning breakout methods you have mentioned before?

Just my own thoughts.

Either way, they both seem to produce a good profit level. Let us know how you get on.

Cheers

Darren
 

wysinawyg

Active member
186 1
Depending on whether you think you can take the string of losses without flitting to another system ;-) I'd say clearly B.

A would probably be easier to stick with psychologically if you scaled back, but B would be much bigger opportunity for leverage.

wysi
 

al-motor

Active member
249 0
JT-

I think as WYSI says, it depends on your personality.........we are continually told that a method has to psychologically sit comfortable.

They will always have good and bads- i think just take the one u are comfortable with !!

p.s. are these computerise results, or have u traded them !??! BIG differenece, regarding slippage ! I know a guy who had a system which produced about $7/8k per month on the S&P, but by the time u took out slippage/commish etc, u were left with peanuts...........


Al
 
 
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

But it's thanks to our sponsors that access to Trade2Win remains free for all. By viewing our ads you help us pay our bills, so please support the site and disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock