MACD(Histogram) Divergence

[TheWolf]

Which gives a stronger signal? (MACD line divergence or MACD histogram divergence)

Thanks!

 

[forexguru99]

Which gives a stronger signal? (MACD line divergence or MACD histogram divergence)

Thanks!

i rely more on the line

 

[Grey1]

Which gives a stronger signal? (MACD line divergence or MACD histogram divergence)

Thanks!

Both signals are irrelevant, naive, and not any guide to future continuation of the trend ..... May I suggest before using these indicators , study the underlying assumptions made in their design .. you might even consider throwing them out da window before using them .. start by questioning where the default values in the MA comes from .. further info can be found on the link below

http://www.trade2win.com/boards/showthread.php?p=75573&highlight=default#post75573

PS:-- some times I wonder how some WALL STREET technicians still use MACD or MA and get paid for their analysis lol

 

[TheWolf]

Both signals are irrelevant, naive, and not any guide to future continuation of the trend ..... May I suggest before using these indicators , study the underlying assumptions made in their design .. you might even consider throwing them out da window before using them .. start by questioning where the default values in the MA comes from .. further info can be found on the link below

http://www.trade2win.com/boards/showthread.php?p=75573&highlight=default#post75573

PS:-- some times I wonder how some WALL STREET technicians still use MACD or MA and get paid for their analysis lol

When I click on the link - it says i don't have permission to access it.

 

[Grey1]

When I click on the link - it says i don't have permission to access it.

Perhaps a moderator can shift this thread to the main forum

thanks