Short selling banned in UK

Does this effect the Indices? Can I still short the FTSE 100? I only spreadbet but got a message from IG stating they would be adhering to this legislation.

I guess you should be able to - futures are not affected.
 
question is why would you short-this is only going 1 way.

interested to see how the FTSE is calculated with financials taken out.....or will they take them out?
 
I think this is a stupid idea tbh.

Then again, the things I've seen on the TV recently, I'm not surprised.
 
Naked Short selling eh.
With out derivatives these markets will stand still as liquidity will dry up.
FSA is a regulator, but these people don't really understand the markets they regulate.
Spread betters will still operate.

Anyone tries phoning IG Index to put large sell orders on there stock ?
Wonder what reaction you would get on multiple limit orders to sell large positions ?

Personally I hate spread betting companies and they should be avoided at all costs as direct acces is more cost affective and more reliable
 
Pasted from IG's site. Will the FSA send the heavies round today?
............................

Trading short
Going short is a simple way of capitalising on a downward trend. For example, should you feel the outlook for the FTSE 100 will continue to be poor you might choose to 'sell' our Daily FTSE 100 bet at £5/point.

Say we are quoting 5101 - 5103 when you open the trade, and by the time you close your position the price has fallen to 4939 - 4941. You would stand to make 5101 (your opening 'sell' price) minus 4941 (your closing 'buy' price) = 160 x £5/point = £800.

Of course, if the market surprised you by turning upwards, the same trade could result in an equal or greater loss.

...................................
 
since what time exactly? .. where's your info coming from? .. have the shorts dried up since the announcement? .. anyway I guess we will find out what the effect of this ban will be.. if the market stabilises and no-more banks are hunted to extinction .. then we can surmise that the big shorters were causing a problem, if the market bombs and kills banks then we can say that .. well ..big naked shorters were not to blame [magnifying the problems out of all reason] .. come back all is forgiven

FT Alphaville » Blog Archive » HBOS: Where are the shorts?

FT Alphaville » Blog Archive » Short paranoia

"You’ll perhaps also notice the weekly change in value of stocks on loan. Short positions have been being unwound all week, and prices have still crashed."
 
Last edited:
Shorting is a mechanism that's been integral for donkeys years, like most of the other posters i'm wondering about liquidity and volatility in the future. Will it be good for traders or bad? It's always a traders market, i know, i'm interested in how all this will pan out.
 
Shorting is a mechanism that's been integral for donkeys years, like most of the other posters i'm wondering about liquidity and volatility in the future. Will it be good for traders or bad? It's always a traders market, i know, i'm interested in how all this will pan out.

I agree, it'll be interesting to see how it works out - no idea what's going to happen really.

I imagine worst case scenario (for bulls) would be something like:
1) Massive unsustainable rally due to perception that ban in shorting means problems have been fixed.
2) People wishing to short have to rely on put buying, and put sellers can't hedge their risk by shorting, driving up the price of puts.
3) Expensive puts mean insuring long positions becomes very expensive, and liquidation seems like the safest option - heavy institutional selling.
4) Prices drop despite shorts ban - scares away new longs from Friday morning, as it suggests bigger underlying issues rather than just speculation from shorters - market gets crushed.

Who knows what will happen?
 
How stupid are the people who are in charge of our countries? This ban makes sense only if the authorities believe there are no underlying reasons for the fall in the banks. This is essentially an artificial way to stop the price from going down. Ultimately, this is going to lead to a bigger disaster. If Halifax is essentailly ****ed, there is nothing they can do to stop it from collapsing, short of printing money and handing it out, which will postpone the problem.

What they are doing here is worse than bailing the banks out: they are interfering with the normal workings of the market. The only honest thing in this markets is to short the banks. They will do anything to cover their asses after lending irresponsibly to anyone who could stand straight at 5% for years and years. Halifax was not even doing credit checks on people provided they had other loans with them. Self-serving wankers should be allowed to go bankrupt. Let them fail and the system will clean itself up over time. We are a bunch of pussies for letting this to happen.
 
How stupid are the people who are in charge of our countries? This ban makes sense only if the authorities believe there are no underlying reasons for the fall in the banks. This is essentially an artificial way to stop the price from going down. Ultimately, this is going to lead to a bigger disaster. If Halifax is essentailly ****ed, there is nothing they can do to stop it from collapsing, short of printing money and handing it out, which will postpone the problem.

What they are doing here is worse than bailing the banks out: they are interfering with the normal workings of the market. The only honest thing in this markets is to short the banks. They will do anything to cover their asses after lending irresponsibly to anyone who could stand straight at 5% for years and years. Halifax was not even doing credit checks on people provided they had other loans with them. Self-serving wankers should be allowed to go bankrupt. Let them fail and the system will clean itself up over time. We are a bunch of pussies for letting this to happen.


Yeh, in terms of cycles, then it's a knee-jerk tampering to buy (pardon the pun) some time, and to stem a humungous overshoot to the downside. But to what degree can the markets really be tampered without an ultra fast (in terms of the big cycle) reworking of money values accross the board, globally.
 
Yeh, in terms of cycles, then it's a knee-jerk tampering to buy (pardon the pun) some time, and to stem a humungous overshoot to the downside. But to what degree can the markets really be tampered without an ultra fast (in terms of the big cycle) reworking of money values accross the board, globally.

They have been Tampering with the markets for ages, Paul. That is the basic problem. Everything was valued at stupid levels, from houses to securities, based on interest rates that defied belief. The banks behaved like there was no tommorrow, like things couldn't go sour. When they get fukced, we bail them with tax money or allow the government to intervene in the market and stop them from the crash they deserve. This is socialism for the rich.
 
They have been Tampering with the markets for ages, Paul. That is the basic problem. Everything was valued at stupid levels, from houses to securities, based on interest rates that defied belief. The banks behaved like there was no tommorrow, like things couldn't go sour. When they get fukced, we bail them with tax money or allow the government to intervene in the market and stop them from the crash they deserve. This is socialism for the rich.


Seems like the way.
 
They have been Tampering with the markets for ages, Paul. That is the basic problem. Everything was valued at stupid levels, from houses to securities, based on interest rates that defied belief. The banks behaved like there was no tommorrow, like things couldn't go sour. When they get fukced, we bail them with tax money or allow the government to intervene in the market and stop them from the crash they deserve. This is socialism for the rich.

Exactly, it's their own cheap and easy money that created this.
Let's blame it on the speculators this time :rolleyes: so we don't have to look at what we did to create this in the first place...
 
Its total madness,in what they have done,will it be oil next if it starts to get back up towards $150, would they stop all the longs?this would not suprise me,its there mess that they have created,and brown is trying to blame it on the traders,he really has lost the plot,if the banks were not in such a poor state,largely because of his last 10 years,then there would not be the aggressive short selling that we have seen,and all this will create is a false market,until it implodes.
 
Is it still possible to short through an etf or are these engineered with actual short positions? Don't quite understand how these 'short' funds converge to the actual value....

Dan
 
I don't get why the SB co's have implimented the shorting ban. Surley as bookies the ban doesn't apply to them, unless they really do hedge their book in the underlying and are just protecting themselves.


dd
 
I've always thought that they hedge their book when they can't balance it and just think what would happen if they were the only place where one could short. They'd be inundated.

Split
 
They have been Tampering with the markets for ages, Paul. That is the basic problem. Everything was valued at stupid levels, from houses to securities, based on interest rates that defied belief. The banks behaved like there was no tommorrow, like things couldn't go sour. When they get fukced, we bail them with tax money or allow the government to intervene in the market and stop them from the crash they deserve. This is socialism for the rich.

The Banks are laughing all the way to the bank. If they were uncertain about taking unjustified risk before, they don't need to be now ........... just so long as they get in before the regulators go completely over the top.....
 
This short selling banning crap is another short term near sighted 'look at us we are addressing the problem' publicity stunt. Banks should be going under. Thats the only way to fix this problem.
 
Last edited:
Top