Forexmospherian
Legendary member
- Messages
- 39,928
- Likes
- 3,306
Lets analyse a GU trade from yesterday afternoon
Hi Guys
We do have some 1 30 pm news today - and so whilst we are awaiting and in between the scalps lets analyse a trade from yesterday
I liked it as a scalp - entry not bad and easy a RR of 2 or 3 if on scalp size stops
As I was not here - I could not join in - but was amazed by the call on this thread
First of all -
No stop size and no description - ie Scalp or Swing etc............ x
No 1st or 2 nd target or aim ? .............. x
No mention of why - is its normal method - or one off ?? ........... x
We need to look at it more as it was near a main support at 5400 and was a fairly good time - ie in a TW
But the GU was bear bias - so were was R's etc etc
Is it a scalp I thought on first read - but anyway "liked" it - thought would love to comment
BUT
Its in a journal not open to me - as Tar says - that does not sound too good a trading journal were only the select can discuss ?
Anyway lets look at the trade
Did it last 30 mins with no breach under 5400 or 5407 ? - Yes
Well thats good - it meant it should try up more
Where's interim R ? - 5427 - 35 area - dynamic and horizontal
Where did he exit - 5419 / 20 - OK only 12 pips - but still OK as profit
What price did it make after 30 mins - 5432 - ok another 12 pips higher
What do you do an interim R's if in TW and price is rejected ? - sell ?
What happened after 5432 ?
What happened after 3 21 pm and 3 39 pm
100 pip fall thats all
Did Tar take a sell ???............ NO - why not ?? - dont know ??
Is this a good trade journal ???
Please let me know what you think guys ??
This is the trader who as the cheek to say this thread is a joke![Laugh :LOL: :LOL:]()
Hi Guys
We do have some 1 30 pm news today - and so whilst we are awaiting and in between the scalps lets analyse a trade from yesterday
![197916d1440761535-intraday-live-short-term-trading-calls-expert-retail-forex-trader-gu-tar-call-270815.png](/proxy.php?image=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.trade2win.com%2Fboards%2Fattachments%2Fdiscretionary-trading%2F197916d1440761535-intraday-live-short-term-trading-calls-expert-retail-forex-trader-gu-tar-call-270815.png&hash=09c274430374d2a844e5039d4a18453a)
I liked it as a scalp - entry not bad and easy a RR of 2 or 3 if on scalp size stops
As I was not here - I could not join in - but was amazed by the call on this thread
First of all -
No stop size and no description - ie Scalp or Swing etc............ x
No 1st or 2 nd target or aim ? .............. x
No mention of why - is its normal method - or one off ?? ........... x
We need to look at it more as it was near a main support at 5400 and was a fairly good time - ie in a TW
But the GU was bear bias - so were was R's etc etc
Is it a scalp I thought on first read - but anyway "liked" it - thought would love to comment
BUT
Its in a journal not open to me - as Tar says - that does not sound too good a trading journal were only the select can discuss ?
Anyway lets look at the trade
![197918d1440762356-intraday-live-short-term-trading-calls-expert-retail-forex-trader-gu-270815pm.png](/proxy.php?image=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.trade2win.com%2Fboards%2Fattachments%2Fdiscretionary-trading%2F197918d1440762356-intraday-live-short-term-trading-calls-expert-retail-forex-trader-gu-270815pm.png&hash=069b6d6eca7ba8c4df5dec7c5057c65d)
Did it last 30 mins with no breach under 5400 or 5407 ? - Yes
Well thats good - it meant it should try up more
Where's interim R ? - 5427 - 35 area - dynamic and horizontal
Where did he exit - 5419 / 20 - OK only 12 pips - but still OK as profit
What price did it make after 30 mins - 5432 - ok another 12 pips higher
What do you do an interim R's if in TW and price is rejected ? - sell ?
What happened after 5432 ?
What happened after 3 21 pm and 3 39 pm
100 pip fall thats all
Did Tar take a sell ???............ NO - why not ?? - dont know ??
Is this a good trade journal ???
Please let me know what you think guys ??
This is the trader who as the cheek to say this thread is a joke