Custom Indicator - which one?

malincho99

Junior member
Messages
16
Likes
0
Hi everybody!
I am new in Forex trading and wonder which one custom indicator to use .Please share your experience!
 
A custom indicator, by definition, is one someone develops for themself. There is no responsitory of them from which to choose. Aside from that, there is no such thing as one best indicator.
 
A custom indicator, by definition, is one someone develops for themself. There is no responsitory of them from which to choose. Aside from that, there is no such thing as one best indicator.


That is a matter of opinion.Some bank traders use stochastics.

I backtested many indicators using same criteria , a combination of multitime frame stochastics is the best so far.

Anyway most of you need to learn about indicators and how they work and how to apply them correctly.

A combination of RSI and stochastics is also very good.
 
I backtested many indicators using same criteria , a combination of multitime frame stochastics is the best so far.

I too have reviewed and tested more indicators than I care to remember. While I am versed enough in many to apply them in market analysis (which I have to do for my job), I do not trade my own account based on any of them. This is not to say individuals cannot find certain indicators useful, as they may help frame the market in a way which suits them. I just long ago made the commitment to focus on price action rather than something one layer (or more) removed and with inherent lag.
 
I too have reviewed and tested more indicators than I care to remember. While I am versed enough in many to apply them in market analysis (which I have to do for my job), I do not trade my own account based on any of them. This is not to say individuals cannot find certain indicators useful, as they may help frame the market in a way which suits them. I just long ago made the commitment to focus on price action rather than something one layer (or more) removed and with inherent lag.

Worth paying attention to in my opinion.
 
I too have reviewed and tested more indicators than I care to remember. While I am versed enough in many to apply them in market analysis (which I have to do for my job), I do not trade my own account based on any of them. This is not to say individuals cannot find certain indicators useful, as they may help frame the market in a way which suits them. I just long ago made the commitment to focus on price action rather than something one layer (or more) removed and with inherent lag.

There is often a great benefit of the lag, and the benefit is the time based confirmation of support or resistance.If you are long on swing strategies,the time lag of the indicator gives confirmation of the underlying trend , as confirmed by scholastics.

There is also a clearly misunderstanding of how to apply indicators and when to apply them .Price action on its own on a single lower time frame is no better than heads or tails.

Look for rsi to become oversold and later stochastics to start to rise .enter long .Look for RSI to become overbought and later stochastics to fall .Get this confirmed by trend lines and price action.

Look at stochastics/rsi on daily ,4 hour , hourly and 15 min time frames, along with price action and trend lines , and if trader can execute the plan , it really is a holy grail.

If traders can't use the free indicators and make money, they never will either with or without custom indicators.
 
Look at stochastics/rsi on daily ,4 hour , hourly and 15 min time frames, along with price action and trend lines , and if trader can execute the plan , it really is a holy grail.

There is nothing in RSI or Stochastics or most other indicators which cannot be determined looking strictly at price. It takes experience, of course, but so too does the profitable application of indicators.
 
Hi RT,

I disagree, divergence is just one example of an indicators use than can not be replicated by looking exclusively at price.
 
Hi RT,

I disagree, divergence is just one example of an indicators use than can not be replicated by looking exclusively at price.

So trader's hallucinations of where price will be heading can also not be replicated by price,.

If you know how to use indicators correctly , they need to be confirmed by price before they can be considered as used correctly
 
I disagree, divergence is just one example of an indicators use than can not be replicated by looking exclusively at price.

And I will disagree right back. Overbought/oversold indicators are largely based on relative price levels and/or momentum. An experienced chartist can most definitely read both things, at least in general terms, from a chart and see when a situation which would show as an indicator divergence is setting up.
 
In my short time of trading I've found indicators to be more of a hindrance to my trading than a help. That's not to say they don't work or anything this is just my experience. I found that by looking at whether two lines cross over or if an oscillator is up or down meant I was not looking at what the price was doing. Watching price to me is the most important thing. It's where I make/lose my money. The price determines when I enter the market and when I get out. Watching indicators clouds this judgement as I am relying on two or more variables. If you throw enough lines on a chart the price will apear to react to one of these lines. Take them off and after time you can clearly see how the price moves.

I only use S/R now on a daily T/F and my trading has come on in leaps and bounds. I've tried quite literally hundreds of strategies and systems in the last few years, some work for a while some never do. This has a lot to do with my personality too. Finding a strategy that works well for you is as much as finding the holy grail. But you need to write it yourself! You need to have confidence in the system. Writing a trading plan based around moving averages or MACD crossovers or whether the price is overbought or oversold etc... will get you nowhere over time.

I'm not trying to sound like a guru here, at all. I'm just telling my tale as not so long ago I was in the position of the OP. I was looking at all the indicators and custom indictors I could find. I was trying to find the holy grail. I wasn't looking at the bigger picture.... what is the PRICE doing.
 
I have customised the free indicators to make them work properly , to suit my trading style.Custom indicators can use free indicators or their own criteria or a combination of both or combination of all plus price action.
 
I'd have to agree with ODT for once, Stochs on multiple time frames can be very useful but you do still have to apply discretion and not trade off the indicator alone. Overbought/oversold areas are less usefull IMO. And of course your trade management following entry is absolutely key. Many things used in PA are lagging as well BTW - trend lines and price charts themselves are lagging databases for example.

If you consider looking at the daily with 5,3,3 and around 20,12,12/25,15,15Stochs what do you see? The higher Stoch shows if the market is trending on the weekly, and the lower stoch shows pullbacks on the daily. Adding a couple of moving averages (don't look for a cross it just saves time drawing trend lines in) helps in taking the 'with trend' moves rather than the countertrend ones. So this is a trade on the weekly with timing on the daily.

The other way of using them is from the bottom up rather than the top down which is how price is actually moving so you're lookng at the stoch to do something for example on the 5 min, then 15 min then the hourly - so here we're trading on the hourly and hopefully have the smaller timeframes building up a head of steam to push the hourly in the same direction, this tends to be more of a countertrend strategy which by it's nature can be risker but gets you in at the start of a move.

All of this of course can be done purely with PA so yes, the indicators aren't really needed at all, but where they are quite useful in showing what's going on from different time perspectives all on the one chart.

I wouldn't recommend using the Stochs as an indication of when to exit at all, just as a rough guider to show the area where to try to pin the tail on the donkey, much the same as drawing in trend lines etc.
 
Hi everybody!
I am new in Forex trading and wonder which one custom indicator to use .Please share your experience!


Look at my 5 custom indicators + stochastics on the chart.Which indicator do you guys believe is my best custom indicator?
 

Attachments

  • odt custom.bmp
    1.7 MB · Views: 145
F**k knows:LOL:

You can read charts and and look at indicator lines

I prefer the second from the bottom, stoch trendline break 15m , filtered with 2 bar confirmation , with 4 h and 15 min stoch

Third from bottom is stoch RSI also good.

Fourth from bottom is cci/volatility breakout/stoch combo

2 nd from top is contrarian

Top is probability manager

Got a dozen others .:LOL: Pity I can execute the game plan on platform.
 
Top