SaxoBank trading experience

azimut50

Newbie
Messages
9
Likes
0
Dear Traders, I want to ask your help. I live in East Europe and wont to start to trade FX at a reliable broker. The only reliable broker I know and can work with from my country is SAXOBANK.
A russian speaking forums describe this broker as the best you can find, but Europian tells other. If anybody works please tell me your opinions about it, concretely about huge spreads, increasing to 100-200pips and jumping rates/
Thanks in advance and sorry for my english,
regards.
 
Hi Azimut

I use Saxobank bank and have done for many years, no problems, reliable, quick execution and small spreads 1-3 on the pairings I trade anyway. You should be fine with them, the only issue is the initial margin, large compared to SB company's, but if your sufficiently funded you should be ok, but check that out first before you comit your money. Good luck
 
Dinos, thank you for your fast reply.
One more issue that disturbs me is a money return transfer. Can you tell me something about it, please. And what about a technical faults in software or servers on real account.
Also ask other honorable traders to share their experience, bad or good, especially BAD/
regards and thanks
 
Platform issues

I keep finding that the summary page does not always load, showing your open positions which is also a quick way for closing or opening on existing positions. In fast moving markets this annoying. A close down and restart does not fix this and it is regular & random. All this whilst the rest of the platform is working.

They should also have a download to excel option on executed trades , if the banks can do it with bank statements why can't brokers this would allow P&L analysis, or at least offer some Basic P&L analysis themselves across CFD's Forex, futures etc.. I have yet to find a broker platform that does this however, so this a general complaint, but as saxo positions itself as the more serious upper end client platform, they are missing a trick here.

Other foibles are if you have contingent orders it will not always let you cover these manually before the stops are hit and exercised by entering a new order to cover.

So you have to go cancel them first then go back, which is messy and slow.

They also will hold covered trades in your blotter for awhile treating it as separate short if you had a long of similar values with a contingent order, even though they are balanced off.

On CFD's they state the short could be unwound if the market required it yet its actually a close of an open position so not sure what would happen if the ever recalled a covered long and treated it as a short which could be withdrawn.


Also the CFD graphs often do not load in a similar way. Just says 'can't find' and if you trade technically you have no site of basic charting unless you have separate live feed from someone else. Especially if you just wish to pick a recent level low/high for trade implementation.

Sometimes the summary page does not refresh either and you need to request a manual refresh. Whilst the rest of the platform is updating.

Finally I found out by going through a intermediary I could get level 2, which has not been provided to me having gone direct which annoys me.

I trade Break out's with various targets to be hit with different levels of trade exposure to be lifted at profit takes.

Their contingent system has only one profit take level, so you have to manually enter a different amount of stock to be covered, then mentally keep the next level and hope to be around to enter the new take profit for the next level once the first has been hit.

Which in fast moving and reversing break outs is sub optimal. Without a separate eSignal live feed I would on occasion feel quiet helpless, this runs without breaks showing it is not my broadband (I have Virgin Media and the 50 Mb package, which is largely the best home use internet in the UK for real performance, directly cabled to trading PC's, ie not wireless).

I remain perplexed how an intermediary will provide me better through through Primed CFD's who introduce to Saxo and IG Index. I would have to open a new account there to get the better level 2 (with Saxo) because of account manager and commission issues I assume.

Clients should get this double standard feel.

Finally whilst typing this the chat bo keeps pinging open and my cursor is then placed there as I am a bit of look down typist I ended up writing half my post in a chat forum. I don't mind it popping up if there is announcement, but its annoying if you have other items you work on.

Apart from this I would say it is better than the basic spreadbet platforms out there, but far from what it could be for now.
 
They should also have a download to excel option on executed trades , if the banks can do it with bank statements why can't brokers this would allow P&L analysis, or at least offer some Basic P&L analysis themselves across CFD's Forex, futures etc.. I have yet to find a broker platform that does this however, so this a general complaint, but as saxo positions itself as the more serious upper end client platform, they are missing a trick here.
Try this: go to the "Trades Executed" or "Trades Booked" page, type Ctrl-A and Ctrl-C, open a new Excel spreadsheet and type Ctrl-V. The data should paste into Excel and you should then be able to write formulas to extract all sort of useful information.

Finally whilst typing this the chat bo keeps pinging open and my cursor is then placed there as I am a bit of look down typist I ended up writing half my post in a chat forum. I don't mind it popping up if there is announcement, but its annoying if you have other items you work on.
That's one of the most annoying things about the platform, I actually asked them and was told that you couldn't disable the chat window altogether. The second annoying thing in my opinion is the complete lack of an automated trading solution, they have gotten rid of TradeCommander which looked promising and they haven't replaced it with anything so far.
 
Try this: go to the "Trades Executed" or "Trades Booked" page, type Ctrl-A and Ctrl-C, open a new Excel spreadsheet and type Ctrl-V. The data should paste into Excel and you should then be able to write formulas to extract all sort of useful information.


That's one of the most annoying things about the platform, I actually asked them and was told that you couldn't disable the chat window altogether. The second annoying thing in my opinion is the complete lack of an automated trading solution, they have gotten rid of TradeCommander which looked promising and they haven't replaced it with anything so far.

Thanks QS, sent post to acc mngr - apparently 'stopping broadcast' in tools menu will stop chat pings. I have not tried it yet.
 
Thanks for your replies, but no one told anything about the increasing of spreads till 100-200 pips(I found it on other forums) during news, or this is lies?
 
Thanks for your replies, but no one told anything about the increasing of spreads till 100-200 pips(I found it on other forums) during news, or this is lies?

Basically the quotes go RFQ from streaming approx 30 seconds before and after a news announcement, this is their protection against news traders and sniping, the spreads can go wide on these occasions as they do everywhere else.

As for the spreads you mention, of course it is possible.
 
GloballyRelaxed,
So all this about spreads is applicable only for a short period in time of news? correct?
 
Last edited:
GloballyRelaxed,
And tell me please how long do you work in SAXO on real?

Have used their platform on and off for a number of years, and your correct it is usually around the news/figure release/intervention etc etc etc where it reverts to RFQ for a period of time.
 
Last edited:
Have used their platform on and off for a number of years, and your correct it is usually around the news/figure release/intervention etc etc etc where it reverts to RFQ for a period of time.
Yesterday had a telephone conversation with their manager, he told that quotes on real and demo account comes from one server otherwise - equal. What can you tell me about this?
 
Yesterday had a telephone conversation with their manager, he told that quotes on real and demo account comes from one server otherwise - equal. What can you tell me about this?

Would not have a clue , went straight to the live platform.
 
Basically the quotes go RFQ from streaming approx 30 seconds before and after a news announcement, this is their protection against news traders and sniping, the spreads can go wide on these occasions as they do everywhere else.

As for the spreads you mention, of course it is possible.

I have no info on that.
 
Can not understand! When I hedg my deal by the double opposite position it shuts in the night and after I see opened only half of doubled position!!! May be I do something wrong?
 
FIFO..

First in first out

My Platform regulary breaks connection or has a fault that sees it 'shut down', whilst my eSignal platform on the same Broadband soldiers on. Its a lot more robust the live eSignal streaming.

Its annoying as I don't have equities on eSignal (just FX) and relied on the Platform for live feed.
 
Asked SAXO manager just now, he told that such happends only on demo, for real, in condition of openning of connected stoploss or takeproffit orders, positions do not shut. Did anybody had such experience exactly on REAL?
 
Top