******: How a Dealing Desk Broker can cheat you with Automatic Slippage

This is a discussion on ******: How a Dealing Desk Broker can cheat you with Automatic Slippage within the Forex Brokers forums, part of the Commercial category; Moderator said: "****** Representative, You have indicated that a 40k withdrawal could be processed by some method right now. This ...

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old Nov 10, 2017, 8:11am   #61
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread Moderator said:

"****** Representative,

You have indicated that a 40k withdrawal could be processed by some method right now. This means that any limitations on the methods you are using to pay Foixx do not apply to some other withdrawal methods which are available to other clients.

At most brokers, if I deposit by any means and make a profit, the usual procedure is to withdraw my initial deposit by the original deposit method/ Any profits can then be withdrawn by any supported withdrawal method, subject to me verifying that the account I'm withdrawing to be verified as belonging to me.

If other clients can successfully make large withdrawals by other means, why won't ****** permit Foixx to utilize these other methods? He's already indicated a willingness to make a modest deposit by other means to satisfy any AML concerns.

Please provide a list of all available methods of withdrawals supported by ****** and the requirements Foixx would have to meet in order to be able to use these."
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Nov 10, 2017, 9:46am   #62
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread Dear ****** Rep, have you realized that AsstModerator boxed you into a corner !!!! (compliments to you...AsstModerator)

Please, avoid to provide another of your typical....vague, evasive and ambiguous answer and admit once for all that my case is absolutely atypical.....and that all of your other clients can stay relaxed, because they will never have any problems with their withdrawals.

Admit that something went wrong with your risk control procedure relating to my trading activity and that you have lost money against me in your MM MT4 Micro Account (a lot of other Brokers are pure ECN with the exception of their Micro Account, where, in consideration of the reduced and limited trading volume, they acts as a Market Maker).....and now you can assure me that you have the will to refund me completely (precisely because you are honest and reputable), but you need only some time to recover these losses, without impact negatively over your other currently active clients.........as I said I can understand if this is the case.
After that .......point out some new restrictive limitations for your Micro Account....Max deposit, Max volume, etc.......and it will all fall into place !

On the contrary, if you persist with your self-destructive approach......the only other road to follow for you at the moment is to pay me next week at least a 40000€ withdrawal request, given that you publicly admitted in your last reply: "A customer who places a single request of 40k should not encounter any issues with withdrawing"

Since from your client area appears that you can use only Neteller or Skrill for clients withdrawals.......this means that, like with any other client, you are able to refund 40000€ in one single withdrawal request, using one of these two methods.

I inform you that I already have two 40000€ withdrawal requests submitted, one with Neteller dated 1 September and one with Skrill dated 8 October (images attached), since, after my forced account closure, I had submitted withdrawal requests with every amount possible, in order to facilitate your payments.

Get to this point, I really think that another evasive answer, besides having a devastating effect for your reputation, will sound only as a teasing.......and I think that it's not a good idea to make fun of FPA.
Attached Thumbnails
screenshot33.jpg   screenshot34.jpg  
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Nov 10, 2017, 9:10pm   #63
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread The Broker's reply:

Dear AsstModerator,

You will find all our withdrawal methods here: https://www.******.com/deposit-and-withdrawal/

The proposed idea of depositing a modest amount via other methods will be in violation of section 13.7 of our Customer Agreement, which reads as follows:

´´In case the account was deposited by various means, withdrawal shall be performed via the same means proportionally to the deposited amounts.´´

In this case, foixx would have to deposit an amount equivalent to all his Neteller deposits to enable whatever other means of withdrawals.

Also, what is important to realise is that the proportional rate between the payments methods used by the client must be maintained to satisfy the AML verification process. Regrettably this is not the case in foixx’s situation.

And in relation to our latest post, it seems like it has been disregarded and only the first sentence has been taken into consideration. Therefore, we shall repeat once again, that we are bound by a daily limitation and to ensure a smooth payouts schedule foixx will receive his funds on weekly basis as per agreement.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Kind regards,
****** Rep.
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Nov 11, 2017, 11:13am   #64
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread Despite I prayed the Broker to stop providing this kind of ambiguous, vague and evasive answers........no way !!!.....this his last reply is "the mother" of all the contradictory answers.

"You will find all our withdrawal methods here: https://www.******. com/deposit-and-withdrawal/"
It's clear that ****** offers only two methods for withdrawals: Skrill and Neteller. This means that ALL his clients can withdraw using ONLY these two methods.

"In this case, foixx would have to deposit an amount equivalent to all his Neteller deposits to enable whatever other means of withdrawals."
But....what are you talking about....what other means of withdrawals?.....you don't offer any other means and I'm already payed using Neteller and Skrill !....your only two means !
In fact....: "With all due respect to Foixx’s posts and reference to our customer agreement we are unable to withdraw his funds via bank wire."

"A customer who places a single request of 40k should not encounter any issues with withdrawing."
This hipotetical client would be payed using Skrill or Neteller, like anybody else. So.... you would be able to pay 40000€ in one single request (or in several little splitted requests in exceptional cases of high demands in withdrawals, but in any case payed ALL in few days, in compliance with your Customer Agreement....so the client has not any issue with it), while at the same time, you can state that I can't have FOR SURE ("****** cannot pay out foixx’s funds all at once due to certain limitations") this kind of high amounts in few time, with consequently.....MONTHS AND MONTHS of waiting to have payed back all my money.

Maybe that my case is atypical? ......"We typically process all withdrawals in one request, but in this specific case we had to ask foixx to submit several withdrawal requests."........"Also, we will not sacrifice other clients’ withdrawals to be able to satisfy foixx"
But ......no....because you wrote as well: "To clarify we never considered foixx’s case atypical."

In conclusion........I SURRENDER ! Really impossible to understand something here, without any clear and non-contradictory answers.

At the same time I have a good news. Yesterday I have received another 5000€ payment, adding to 10000€ this Monday....a total of 15000€ this week. (60000€ remained in the account....was 105.000€ at the beginning of this thread)
I couldn't help noticing his increase willingness to resolve the situation, despite his pretty clear financial difficulties.

And in addition, while in his previous reply, the Broker wrote: "You will receive a 10,000 withdrawal this week. We will do our best to ensure that this amount is being paid to you on weekly basis...."........that, as his usual, it's not a clear promise.....it could happen, but, at the same time, it couldn't happen, despite his "our best to ensure...."......instead this time he was much more clear, writing in his last reply: ".....and to ensure a smooth payouts schedule foixx will receive his funds on weekly basis as per agreement."
I emphasize....AS PER AGREEMENT.....and I was absolutely clear in my previous post that an agreement is reached only if he can assure me a MINIMUM payment of 10000€ a week.

AsstModerator , can FPA take this last answer as a formale promise that this new 10000€ minimum weekly payment will be honored? ( ****** Rep .... talk clearly now if you have to disprove this agreement)
This means that I will have payments for a maximum of another 6 weeks......Good lord willing I will be able to celebrate a peaceful Christmas !....and this compromise, in consideration of all these circumstances, as I said, can be acceptable for me.

In this case........AsstModerator...... before to put a warning in his review page....can you wait if there is someone other client that have a complaint to do about his withdrawals with ******?
Because, if my hypothesis, explained in my previous posts (the Broker has lost money with me in your Market Maker MT4 Micro account), is correct but the Broker doesn't want to admit it......probably in this moment I'm the only client with this kind of withdrawal problem.....and in this case ......a GLOBAL warning, valid for all his clients and new potential clients, in my opinion, couldn't be the fairest solution to apply.

Fairest, in my opinion, will be to proceed with a the Traders Court public voting, only in case the Broker fails to honor the agreement with me.....in order to punish this despicable behavior, exceptionally conducted in my specific case.
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Thanks! The following members like this post: Lee Shepherd
Old Nov 17, 2017, 5:03pm   #65
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread I have just received a weekly payment of 20.000€ with Skrill.....what a nice surprise!....an amount even double compared to the agreement reached.
A total of 35.000€ payed in only 2 weeks against 7 weeks needed with the previous little 5000€ weekly payment ratio.
Only 40.000€ now remains in the account....was 105.000€ at the beginning of this thread.
AsstModerator .......in my view, it's pretty clear that now ****** has really the full willingness to solve my case as soon as possible.
For this reason I'm very optimist about the next weekly payments and so the case may be declared as resolved very soon.
I'll keep you posted.
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Nov 21, 2017, 12:09pm   #66
Joined Sep 2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by foix View Post
I have just received a weekly payment of 20.000€ with Skrill.....what a nice surprise!....an amount even double compared to the agreement reached.
A total of 35.000€ payed in only 2 weeks against 7 weeks needed with the previous little 5000€ weekly payment ratio.
Only 40.000€ now remains in the account....was 105.000€ at the beginning of this thread.
AsstModerator .......in my view, it's pretty clear that now ****** has really the full willingness to solve my case as soon as possible.
For this reason I'm very optimist about the next weekly payments and so the case may be declared as resolved very soon.
I'll keep you posted.
Glad to know you have almost resolved your issue. Next time you will be more careful with choosing a platform you want to trade on especially for large amount of capital
gerryg is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Nov 25, 2017, 3:40pm   #67
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread "For this reason I'm very optimist about the next weekly payments and so the case may be declared as resolved very soon."

Too much beautiful to be true......I spoke too soon !
This week I have received again only a little 5000€ payment....as it was usual before the "supposed" agreement (I hope that this is not only my delusion !)
Considering that.... last week I have received a double amount...20.000€.....I want to be sympathetic and so....I consider the agreement not yet broken up.
Nevertheless I hope that next weeks @****** Rep wants to return to pay me a minimum of 10000€ per week, as per agreement.
I'm very tired to fight....(almost 4 entire months are already passed since my forcibly account closure !) and I very much hope that...this time... the Broker will have really the willingness to honor the agreement for the future.
We shall see !!!
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Dec 2, 2017, 1:59pm   #68
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread A big 20.000€ payment is arrived this week....very well !......I appreciate the effort.
Only 15.000€ still in the account now.
I start again to be optimist and I really hope that all the refund can be completed within the next 2 weeks, as per agreement.
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Dec 6, 2017, 4:31pm   #69
Joined Sep 2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by foix View Post
A big 20.000€ payment is arrived this week....very well !......I appreciate the effort.
Only 15.000€ still in the account now.
I start again to be optimist and I really hope that all the refund can be completed within the next 2 weeks, as per agreement.
Are you going to continue using their services?
gerryg is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Dec 6, 2017, 4:49pm   #70
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by gerryg View Post
Are you going to continue using their services?
The Broker has forcibly closed my trading account at the beginning of August, without provide me any explanation.
He doesn't want me as his client probably because he doesn't like winning clients in his "Fake ECN - Market Maker" MT4 Micro account.
But in any case .....I'm not fully crazy......only full regulated Brokers for me next time !!!
No matter if I have to pay more, the only important thing is to have my withdrawal requests completed within the period specified in the Broker Terms of Use, as a serious and reputable Broker should always do.
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Dec 12, 2017, 3:43pm   #71
Joined Sep 2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by foix View Post
The Broker has forcibly closed my trading account at the beginning of August, without provide me any explanation.
He doesn't want me as his client probably because he doesn't like winning clients in his "Fake ECN - Market Maker" MT4 Micro account.
But in any case .....I'm not fully crazy......only full regulated Brokers for me next time !!!
No matter if I have to pay more, the only important thing is to have my withdrawal requests completed within the period specified in the Broker Terms of Use, as a serious and reputable Broker should always do.
Have you made-up a short list of candidates? Would be really glad to hear your opinion on that matter.
gerryg is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Dec 12, 2017, 4:07pm   #72
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by gerryg View Post
Have you made-up a short list of candidates? Would be really glad to hear your opinion on that matter.
For the moment I have just opened an ECN VIP Account with Tickmill.co.uk FCA regulated.
Seems it has everything it takes to be a very good broker.....we''ll just see !
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Dec 21, 2017, 8:50am   #73
Joined Aug 2012
foix started this thread Even my last payment is arrived today.....now all the refund has been completed.
****** Rep has fully honored our agreement and for this reason, on my part, this case can be considered fully resolved.
****** has showed of not being a Scam Broker, even if he has to work hardly on his transparency about his conditions and limitations applied to his clients.
Thanks again to AsstModerator and FPA for all the help provided.
I would like to take this opportunity to wish to all the forum members a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.
foix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Dec 22, 2017, 10:52pm   #74
Joined Sep 2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by foix View Post
Even my last payment is arrived today.....now all the refund has been completed.
****** Rep has fully honored our agreement and for this reason, on my part, this case can be considered fully resolved.
****** has showed of not being a Scam Broker, even if he has to work hardly on his transparency about his conditions and limitations applied to his clients.
Thanks again to AsstModerator and FPA for all the help provided.
I would like to take this opportunity to wish to all the forum members a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.
Glad to know your issue has been fully resolved. Hope you will find better broker this time.
gerryg is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
How to tell a difference if Your Broker is a Dealing Desk or Non-Dealing Desk vanko123 Forex Brokers 0 Dec 18, 2010 5:34am
Dealing Desk aulifications? SanMiguel General Trading Chat 3 Aug 3, 2010 1:12pm
Non Dealing Desk brokers Trdr Forex 2 Nov 1, 2009 7:04pm
Dealing Desk chilltrader Spread Betting & CFDs 18 Aug 28, 2009 10:01pm

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)