Opinions about WD Gann's theories

[Lee Shepherd]

Hi David,

Happy Sunday to you.

I’m looking forward to your new trading journal. Thanks in advance for sharing.

 

[FXX]

My opinion is you are probably going to waste an amount of time and resources on this that won't yield anything near your expectations. Its arbitrary gobbledegook that like all things interpreted by humans have patterns that are perceived to be what they aren't. It's a cycle of smoke and mirrors that's plagued our race since the dawn of time.



Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

[David Knight]

My opinion is you are probably going to waste an amount of time and resources on this that won't yield anything near your expectations. Its arbitrary gobbledegook that like all things interpreted by humans have patterns that are perceived to be what they aren't. It's a cycle of smoke and mirrors that's plagued our race since the dawn of time.


Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

I just want to make it clear that the journal will not have anything to do with Gann.


My 'expectation' is that journal 2 will be better than journal 1.


As always, I will be aiming for something much harder than Gann...


..................... Simplicity
...........................................................................................................

 

[Brumby]

You're a troll. That speaks volumes


My upcoming new trading journal will 'speak volumes' about TIME and PRICE.


For obvious reasons, I will need to remove your ability to comment on that journal. So I think it's only fair to leave the last word to you.


You could use that opportunity to expand on your one liner-
'Personally I do use Gann's concept of price and time but in a very simplistic manner.'

(For the 3rd time of asking)


Or-


Carry on trolling.


Anyone care sleeping to predict which one Brumby will choose?

The most obvious evidence that a person cannot engage in a conversation of substance is when the rebuttals are ad hominem attacks sprinkled with feign outrage of being called out.

When you actually substantiate your claim that Gann said "time equal price" then I will address the question - not before. You will not get to change the goal post and redirect the conversation. You can either step up or shut up.

 

[Kaeso]

Price can't equal time, that's insane :cheesy:

Are you referring to the 1 X 1 type trend which he considered the "best proportioned"? where they are kinda "equal proportioned"

i am not familiar with Gann btw, and I am puzzled about how one would determine what is a unit of time and what a is a unit of price