Steamroller’s EURUSD Swing Trade Journal

SteamRoller

Member
Messages
70
Likes
15
I’ve decided to start a journal of EURUSD swing trades.

My reason for starting the journal is to improve discipline and consistency in my trading, as well as focussing thought and sharing ideas with others. I have a clear understanding of what I am trying to do, and how. I am not looking to make enormous profits over night, I am looking to achieve consistency in playing out an edge which I am fairly sure exists in my methodology (note ‘fairly sure‘, not ‘absolutely certain‘).

I have back tested the strategy over the last 3 years, and am at the point where I am forward testing it - i.e. trading it with small stakes.

The strategy is discretionary at the higher timeframes (price location / levels) but semi mechanical on the operating timeframe, and with a completely mechanical entry method.

The methodology is this:

Identify price moving to an ‘area of interest’ on the weekly chart. By ‘area of interest’ I mean a level where a reaction has occurred. For example, previous significant relative swing high / low, congestion or range etc. My expectation is that there is an increased statistical chance of a reaction at such levels. This is my ‘overhead’ or higher timeframe. This is the discretionary / subjective bit.

When price is at an area of interest, I will then look at the 8 hour (480 minute chart). This obviously gives 3 bars per day. I am UK based and using 22.00 - 06.00 (Asian session bar), 06.00 - 14.00 (European session bar) and 14.00 to 22.00 (US session bar). I can see two of the bars close and the next open, at 6am and 10pm. I am at work when the 14.00 close occurs.

For example, if the 8 hour chart shows an uptrend (characterised by HHs and HLs) then I will look to enter on a reversal of trend as defined by a bias change on this timeframe. I interpret that to be a break below the most recent (highest) Relative Swing Low. Opposite for downtrends. This would be the first sign of a new downtrend (using this analysis). I am prepared to trade the bias change itself rather than await confirmation (breakthrough, pullback, continuation), due to the entry method (next point below).

The method of entry is using automated entries with 20 pip stop losses, but if the entry is stopped out, a new order to enter is replaced, which remains all the time the 8 hour TA confirms this is applicable. I am using ‘staged’ orders on TradeStation with a series of linked OSOs to simulate automation, but have the orders sent to the broker, rather than rely on running a TradeStation strategy.

The two advantages of this method are (1) you cannot get left behind in a big move by being ‘just stopped out’ and then the market going without you, and (2) if you are just stopped in to a trade which then goes immediately against you, you lose only 20 pips, not the 100 pips + that would be generated by a natural stop size based on TA / ATR for an 8 hour chart on EURUSD. The disadvantage is that if a entry level is reached and price meanders along sideways you can get stopped in and out and so can suffer a number of ‘whips’ before the trade either goes my way, or invalidates, for the reason of subsequent price action. It’s never much more than about 8 hours before I can re-evaluate though.

I am fairly sure (but not certain, hence the journal) that there is an edge in this and that there will be a positive expectancy, based on non-random behaviour / reaction at key levels, getting into trends early, and keeping losses very small, and running trends.

Trades will be run until a bias change against the trade direction, which would / could indicate a trade opportunity in the other direction, subject to being at a suitable (discretionary) level to enter. Initially I am using 2 mini contracts, taking profits on the first around 150-200 pips, and running the second with a trailing stop below /above swing points but with a target of 500 pips, since few swings on the 8 hour TF go much further than 500 pips.

So that’s it really, no fancy indicators, no unrealistic expectations, just based on price triggers at key reaction zones…

I’ll post up charts as trades unfold. Today bias changed to down. I didn’t go short at 1.3760 as I was at work (annoyingly the only bar I don’t see close is at 2pm, it remains to be seen how much of a weakness this is overall), but as we are now biased short I will look for a pullback and short entry possibility. Looking to the weekly chart, potentially there is a weekly pin bar in the making depending on what happens tomorrow.

Obviously though, I will trade what I see on the charts, not opinion…I have no ‘opinion’. I am reacting to what is happening and trying to get on board.

Thanks!

Dave.
 
Last edited:
Cheers, DT.

It remains to be seen whether this entry will 'stick' but by calling the trades in advance at least the performance should be beyond dispute.

Currently short from 1.3615
 
Cheers, DT.

It remains to be seen whether this entry will 'stick' but by calling the trades in advance at least the performance should be beyond dispute.

Currently short from 1.3615

Good luck!
I'll be watching too :)

Peter
 
Bias remains short - just - as long as price holds below 1.37.
Will try for short at 1.3690 if possible.
Otherwise, depending on the current bar's action between now and close (10pm) next entry trigger would be 1.3610.
 
Didn't get 1.3690.
Entries set to sell @ 1.3610 (break below pinbar low) and 1.3490 (swinglow, low of week).

In answer to a question raised: As I am using 'tester' entries with 20 pip stops, previous entries triggered at 1.3615 and 1.3540 stopped out. Basically I'm looking to enter either with the trend (or on change of trend) on 8 hour timeframe, at suitable TA defined levels. If the trade doesn't immediately go my way, I'm out (hence the 20 pip stoploss and replacing orders). The entry levels get modified or improved as dictated by price behaviour.
 
Price has risen and no orders triggered.
Weekly chart still has price at/below weekly interest area - 1.38
Previous 2 weeks' bars rejected that level.
Looking for entry opportunities on 8 hour TF so long as price remains at/below this area.
 

Attachments

  • EU_W_09Feb11.png
    EU_W_09Feb11.png
    25.5 KB · Views: 224
Filled short at 1.3690 and 1.3610.
Price kicking about a bit at the 1.36 RN so expect a few whips here. Fell straight through 1.3690 with no whips.
Next area of interest is 1.3490.
 
Still short from 1.3690 and 1.3610.
Stops for both these entries now at 1.3630.
Hopefully from the point of view of this short trade, today's high will be a relative swing high in the pullback, 1.36 having become a resistance level. If not then I'm ready to bail out for a small profit hence having pulled the stop in to 1.3630.
 
I've been away for a while, hence delay in posting.

I've also got a bit of time off at the minute, so am thinking that without radically changing the rules (I don't want to continually change the rules), I can use 240 min charts rather than 480 min for entry timeframe. Interest areas still picked up from weekly or daily chart and comprise:
* Weekly / Daily chart relative swing highs / lows
* Round numbers
* Confluence of both would be preferable.

Patterns on 240 / 480 min chart, at reaction area:
123 reversals, pinbars.

This gives 'Interest areas' to look for reversal patterns at:
1.3860 W, D chart RSH
1.3740 D chart RSH (at this level now)
1.3525 yesterday's low (just above 'big' RN at 1.35)
 
Good Morning

This is my second post on this forum. I trade EUR/USD however I use another method than you do. I use technicals as well as price action however EUR/USD does not always follow patterns or charts. Fundamental events and other factors intervene. Keep trading whatever method works for you since:) the only thing of importance trading forex is are you winning more money than losing it consistently.

It is nice to have posted in your trading journal.
 
Good Morning

This is my second post on this forum. I trade EUR/USD however I use another method than you do. I use technicals as well as price action however EUR/USD does not always follow patterns or charts. Fundamental events and other factors intervene. Keep trading whatever method works for you since:) the only thing of importance trading forex is are you winning more money than losing it consistently.

It is nice to have posted in your trading journal.

Thanks for your comments Aviel!

Potential Pinbar setup on 240 min chart, will sell a break below the low.
 
Hi there, good luck with this, how are you selecting your stops ( if you're using them at all)?
 
Hi there, good luck with this, how are you selecting your stops ( if you're using them at all)?

Hi Black Swan,

I have two methods. One method is to take 20 pip stops, in the expectation that you'll more than likely get stopped out, and keep putting the entry / new 20 pip stop in each time you get stopped out. Advantage of this is is you don't miss a big move by just getting stopped out, and then the market going without you. Disadvantage is in a sideways day, you can get a lot of whips, so drawdown can be a bit fierce...

Second method, I'm using either a volatility based stop, loosely based on ATR for the entry TF, or putting the stop beyond the event that got me in, e.g. if a pinbar bar then above / below the 'other end' of the pin. Either way, this seems to give traditional stops of around 60 pips.
 
Potential Pinbar setup on 480 (also 240 min) chart.
D chart is at 1.38 RN.
 

Attachments

  • 24Feb2011.png
    24Feb2011.png
    32.9 KB · Views: 160
Top