Is Trump The Next Reagan? Investors Better Brace Themselves


3 ratings



Keith McCullough

17 Feb, 2017

in Indices

The latest bullish meme floating around Wall Street is that President Donald Trump is going to unleash a new era of big fiscal spending. As a result, lackluster U.S. economic growth is going to finally accelerate to the upside. Inflation is going to pick up. In a nutshell, this is the narrative which has triggered a huge rip higher in the U.S. stock market.

Be careful accepting that bullish narrative as gospel.

Take a look at history – it offers investors some interesting perspective. In particular, the post-election market between 1980 and 1982. On November 4, 1980, Ronald Reagan was elected president. The country appeared to be riding high.

What happened?


The stock market rallied – big. In fact, the S&P 500 jumped 7% from the day of Reagan’s victory to the end of November. The market top was in.

Of course, the Reagan administration had its hands full with a serious recession. Stocks fell 22% from the day of Reagan’s presidential win to the August 1982 recession low. When stocks fall over 20% that’s considered a crash.

To be clear, we are not suggesting stocks are headed for a 1980-style crash. What we are suggesting is that Wall Street exuberance may have gotten ahead of itself, similar to Reagan, since Trump won the election.

The economic picture in the early 1980s obviously differs from where we are today. The Federal Reserve was in the process of raising interest rates to historic levels in an effort to fight runaway inflation. The unemployment rate was creeping up. Today, rates are at historic lows and inflation is just beginning to picking up again. Unemployment has been falling since 2009.

In short, Reagan brought out the deficit-spending bazooka to stem the bleeding. Trump is bringing out big fiscal spending to steady U.S. growth and “Make America Great Again.”

No matter what you may think about that, investors believe him. Since November 4th:

  • S&P 500: +5.2%
  • Russell 2000: +13.4%
  • Financials (XLF): +14.2%
  • Industrials (XLI): +9.1%
  • Meanwhile, the 10-year Treasury yield went from 1.72% to 2.32%

Respect those moves. If you missed it, don’t complain. If you nailed it, congratulations. None of that matters now.

What’s next?

On that front, I’ve got more questions than answers:

  • Is the #TrumpTrade already priced-in?
  • Can Trump’s fiscal spending actually prevent the U.S. economy from falling below the third quarter’s 1.5% year-over-year growth (after the peak of 3.3% in the 1Q 2015)?
  • Will a Fed rate hike  prick the frothy stock market bubble - like it did in 2015 - just as it notches another all-time high?
  • 10-year Treasury yields just made a massive move to the upside. Will it stick?

What I can say is that after almost two decades in this business, I’ve learned a number of important lessons. One of them is that it’s okay to admit and say, “I don’t know.” There’s nothing wrong in acknowledging uncertainty the road ahead. In other words, embrace the uncertainty.

You need to be logged in to post comments or rate this article.

I heard about the stock rally that happened in Wall Street. Did you guys heard of the Trump Bump? Do you think the rally’s a good thing? How long do you think it will last?

Mar 23, 2017

Member (5 posts)

Re: Is Trump The Next Reagan? Investors Better Brace Themselves

That was an excellent article, keith! Actually, Even some market bulls are starting to get nervous about the stock rally.

Mar 09, 2017

Banned (1 post)